What can you catch with the old rod?

#1smtoshPosted 10/30/2011 6:27:21 AM
I am more just curious than anything else to know what kinds of pokemon can be caught with the old rod.

I am aware that magikarp is a frequent catch with this rod, but despite what I have read in many different places, I have managed to catch a tentacool on route 32 (morning) and a poliwag on route 31 (day) with it. Anybody else catch anything interesting?
#2lloyd0117Posted 10/30/2011 6:44:02 AM
i read somewhere that goldeen was catchable in or around union cave ...
---
"when I'm in the process of doing something, I do it not because I think it's worth doing, but because I'm trying to MAKE it worth doing."
#3LonelyRonsoPosted 10/30/2011 9:07:24 AM
Hhhhmmm... I'd say teh following:

1: I tough you could only catch Magikarp. I think Magikarp and =Another Pokémon= are avalaible in these routes.

Here's what I THINK that it is:

Old Rod:
Magikarp 90%
Another Pokémon 10%
Super Rod Pokémon 0%

Good Rod:
Magikarp 40%
Another Pokémon 60%
Super Rod Pokémon 0%

Super Rod:
Magikarp 0%
Another Pokémon 50%
Super Rod pokémon 50%

---

That's what I think it is.
#4lloyd0117Posted 10/30/2011 10:41:34 AM
in some of the walkthrough faqs they actually do have the percentages on each routs
---
"when I'm in the process of doing something, I do it not because I think it's worth doing, but because I'm trying to MAKE it worth doing."
#5SunIsGodPosted 11/1/2011 11:33:12 AM
Goldeen, Horsea, Magikarp.
---
Silence is golden. I am golden.
#6SunIsGodPosted 11/1/2011 11:33:35 AM
I mean Krabby instead of Horsea.
---
Silence is golden. I am golden.