This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Denard Robinson or Michael Vick? who is better?

#21LowOnMyPaperPosted 9/1/2012 7:32:12 PM
the one who's black and runs really fast
---
The statement below is true.
Paradoxes suck.
#22xtacb(Topic Creator)Posted 9/1/2012 7:58:41 PM
IWantANewKlug posted...
lmao @ TC's sig

All dat mediocrity


i know, #1 in the world is all dat mediocrity
---
WoW: Talho #11 top warrior dps on 25 Saurfang and Festergut *WorldWide* and #1 world BPC, as of 4/7/10
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/dps/war/9/0/3
#23xtacb(Topic Creator)Posted 9/1/2012 8:01:28 PM
xtacb posted...
IWantANewKlug posted...
lmao @ TC's sig

All dat mediocrity


i know, #1 in the world is all dat mediocrity


LowOnMyPaper posted...
the one who's black and runs really fast


which one is that

anyone watching Michigan vs Bama?

Denard is passing like Vick...
---
WoW: Talho #11 top warrior dps on 25 Saurfang and Festergut *WorldWide* and #1 world BPC, as of 4/7/10
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/dps/war/9/0/3
#24jordan629Posted 9/1/2012 8:11:23 PM
TC still knows little about Vick
---
I will not change this line until the Philadelphia Eagles win a Super Bowl - Started 8-25-05
#25xtacb(Topic Creator)Posted 9/1/2012 8:26:01 PM(edited)
jordan629 posted...
TC still knows little about Vick


and what do you mean by that?

jordan629 posted...
NikoIai posted...
Spoken like people who didn't see Michael Vick in college.


This.

Vick vs. Pat White
Vick vs. Robert Griffin
Vick vs. Denard Robinson
Vick vs. <insert fast black QB here because apparently they're all the same>


Denard Robinson is more similar to Michael Vick than any of the other QBs you listed

RG3 is good player but hes not even a runner, he never has run for more than 850 yards a reason, he does throw for a ton of yards though

---
WoW: Talho #11 top warrior dps on 25 Saurfang and Festergut *WorldWide* and #1 world BPC, as of 4/7/10
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/dps/war/9/0/3
#26EternalWolfPosted 9/1/2012 8:15:29 PM
xtacb posted...
xtacb posted...
IWantANewKlug posted...
lmao @ TC's sig

All dat mediocrity


i know, #1 in the world is all dat mediocrity


LowOnMyPaper posted...
the one who's black and runs really fast


which one is that

anyone watching Michigan vs Bama?

Denard is passing like Vick...


Denard had one good pass all night(from what I watched). It came when Alabama loaded the box, his o-line gave him perfect protection and the DB blew coverage on the WR. Everything else has been complete s*** aside from the TD pass. The TD pass was a pretty bad throw, luckily the DB covering the WR fell down and there wasnt another DB within 5 yards of him.

Cant throw(horrible accuracy), cant run(constantly needs to take plays off due to injury), cant catch. The most important traits for the three major offensive positions and he cant do any of them.
---
As We Go...
http://i42.tinypic.com/2m82zjm.jpg
#27xtacb(Topic Creator)Posted 9/1/2012 8:26:52 PM(edited)


Denard had one good pass all night(from what I watched). It came when Alabama loaded the box, his o-line gave him perfect protection and the DB blew coverage on the WR. Everything else has been complete s*** aside from the TD pass. The TD pass was a pretty bad throw, luckily the DB covering the WR fell down and there wasnt another DB within 5 yards of him.

Cant throw(horrible accuracy), cant run(constantly needs to take plays off due to injury), cant catch. The most important traits for the three major offensive positions and he cant do any of them.


Their career %, TD, yards, etc are pretty similar, they both have throws on target about the same, completing about 55%

both seem sorta glass at this point

and yes i did vote for Vick

---
WoW: Talho #11 top warrior dps on 25 Saurfang and Festergut *WorldWide* and #1 world BPC, as of 4/7/10
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/dps/war/9/0/3
#28Danny_WatkinsPosted 9/1/2012 8:33:15 PM(edited)
Do you even watch Vick? Especially in college, he is not similar in any way outside of his speed to Robinson. Vick has a much stronger arm and had better QB traits at VT than that gimmick Robinson has, which is barely any. Throw all the stats you want at us, this isn't baseball.
#29xtacb(Topic Creator)Posted 9/1/2012 8:43:03 PM(edited)
Danny_Watkins posted...
Do you even watch Vick? Especially in college, he is not similar in any way outside of his speed to Robinson. Vick has a much stronger arm and had better QB traits at VT than that gimmick Robinson has, which is barely any. Throw all the stats you want at us, this isn't baseball.


i said that Denard Robinson is more similar to Vick than the other QBs like Pat White, RG3,

not that they are completely the same

also its quite a difference in stats,

Denard
2300 yards passing, 1400 yards rushing (average)

Vick (in college)
1600 yards passing, 600 yards rushing (average)

http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/michael-vick-1.html
http://espn.go.com/college-football/player/stats/_/id/480237/denard-robinson

and yes i do think Vick is better (probably my fav QB, textbook pocket passing QBs are boring)

---
WoW: Talho #11 top warrior dps on 25 Saurfang and Festergut *WorldWide* and #1 world BPC, as of 4/7/10
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/dps/war/9/0/3
#30jordan629Posted 9/1/2012 8:46:28 PM(edited)
Vick also had a lot less attempts than Robinson

But hey, stats smats...
---
I will not change this line until the Philadelphia Eagles win a Super Bowl - Started 8-25-05