This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Why does Peyton suck in the playoffs?

  • Topic Archived
  1. Boards
  2. Sports and Racing - NFL
  3. Why does Peyton suck in the playoffs?
2 years ago#11
orestes1981 posted...
98_Dam_Straight posted...
You mean the tools that went 11-5 with a rookie?


...and Chuck Strong, Bruce Arians, etc.

It is easy to look like you know nothing when you leave out key points.


But when they were winning with Manning it was all Manning right?
---
Sig? I'm not givin' my sig to a machine.
2 years ago#12
Beats up on lesser competition in the regular season and chokes vs the big time playoff teams
2 years ago#13
VerySikTodayII posted...
Beats up on lesser competition in the regular season and chokes vs the big time playoff teams


Pretty much this
---
Voted best poster on GameFAQs for the past 4 years
2 years ago#14
98_Dam_Straight posted...
orestes1981 posted...
98_Dam_Straight posted...
You mean the tools that went 11-5 with a rookie?


...and Chuck Strong, Bruce Arians, etc.

It is easy to look like you know nothing when you leave out key points.


But when they were winning with Manning it was all Manning right?


Did I say that? Manning needed Bob Sanders to make the team a Super Bowl winning team.
---
Cappin' thine enemy is not exactly something Jesus would do, it's what Suge Knight would do.
-Bill Maher
2 years ago#15
Because he's not playing teams like the Raiders.
---
Gators. Buccaneers. Heat. Phillies. Penguins.
2 years ago#16
You implied when you said they went 2-14 because Manning wasn't playing.
---
Sig? I'm not givin' my sig to a machine.
2 years ago#17
because you need the ability to improvise plays sometimes to win in the playoffs against good teams and he has almost none of that. if he doesn't read the defense pre-snap he's in trouble. Also his defenses have been pretty bad in the playoffs too.
---
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lnwbnmx2Qb1qieluno1_250.gif
2 years ago#18
His play isn't much different, it's usually the defense or the coach that screws the team over. For example, Rahim Moore last year, or Caldwell calling a TO in 2010.
2 years ago#19
Will_Hill_pimp posted...
His play isn't much different, it's usually the defense or the coach that screws the team over. For example, Rahim Moore last year, or Caldwell calling a TO in 2010.


Or Vanderjagt in 2004 or 2005, I believe?
2 years ago#20
EmperorCain posted...
Fact of the matter is that in a great many of his playoff losses, Manning and his offense were to blame. His defense often did a good job in those games, and he and his offense choked big time. Even the one year he won the Super Bowl, he only had one good offensive game, against the Pats, in a game with piss poor officiating that greatly benefited his team.



No excuses.
  1. Boards
  2. Sports and Racing - NFL
  3. Why does Peyton suck in the playoffs?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived