This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

WLC Wins Another Debate

  • Topic Archived
  1. Boards
  2. Religion
  3. WLC Wins Another Debate

User Info: Magyar15

Magyar15
4 years ago#31
LunarAmbience posted...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZabnReL224

Craig couldn't handle a guy outside of forum that encourages his gallop. Put Dawkins on a stage with him, it will appear that he'd been demolished. Put him in a sit-down exchange or video/text exchange, and Craig will fall apart as fast as he did for this guy.


Honestly, whether he was right or not, everything about that guy in the youtube video screams douchebag...
A good man would prefer to be defeated than to defeat injustice by evil means - Sallust

User Info: Proudclad

Proudclad
4 years ago#32
TheoreticalBS's interaction with Craig is laughable. Craig is a fierce opponent. If they sat down and debated, Craig would probably win. Dawkins wouldn't merely "appear" demolished. He WOULD be demolished because his arguments are garbage.
proudclad LAYING DOWN THE SMACK - Error1355
chaoscoalition.net

User Info: PhiZZiZle

PhiZZiZle
4 years ago#33
LunarAmbience posted...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZabnReL224

Craig couldn't handle a guy outside of forum that encourages his gallop. Put Dawkins on a stage with him, it will appear that he'd been demolished. Put him in a sit-down exchange or video/text exchange, and Craig will fall apart as fast as he did for this guy.


Fall apart as he did for this guy.....

You have lost ALL credibility
God made police so that firefighters could have heroes.

User Info: LunarAmbience

LunarAmbience
4 years ago#34
Nope, and whatever.

We're at an impasse. Forever in the hypothetical, it seems.
The above is both true and false.

User Info: Proudclad

Proudclad
4 years ago#35
PhiZZiZle is right. Pretending that Dawkins wouldn't be demolished is laughable. So is insisting that Craig fell apart because of some Youtuber who had some limited interaction with a professional philosopher, intellectual, thinker, etc.
proudclad LAYING DOWN THE SMACK - Error1355
chaoscoalition.net

User Info: LunarAmbience

LunarAmbience
4 years ago#36
Pretending that depriving WLC of his Gish Gallop wouldn't take the wind out of his sails is laughable. So is sitting in astonished disbelief that a professional philosopher, intellectual, thinker, etc. in all of his, ahem... authority managed to make a fool of himself through his interactions with an amateur.
The above is both true and false.

User Info: Proudclad

Proudclad
4 years ago#37
you keep taking for granted your assumption that he made a fool of himself. when quite frankly atheists are so desperate to say that they 'debunked' Craig that they're turning to a tiny interaction with a Youtuber (an interaction that, if complete, would've crushed the Youtuber) as their last means of debunking a powerful and formidable thinker

this is...the very definition of unfortunate.
proudclad LAYING DOWN THE SMACK - Error1355
chaoscoalition.net

User Info: LunarAmbience

LunarAmbience
4 years ago#38
It's simply my belief that if you deprive this "powerful and formidable thinker" of a forum in which this thinker consistently advances rather, eh... practiced and numerous - numerous - nuuumerous (did I emphasize numerous?) points, and you move him to a forum in which time and formal turn-taking are not issues, you would see that he doesn't do as well.

I'm sorry if you can't see that in this particular (and rare, incidentally) interaction. I hope your obvious inclination toward sparkly, shiny authority didn't bias you.
The above is both true and false.

User Info: lasthero

lasthero
4 years ago#39
Proudclad posted...
PhiZZiZle is right. Pretending that Dawkins wouldn't be demolished is laughable. So is insisting that Craig fell apart because of some Youtuber who had some limited interaction with a professional philosopher, intellectual, thinker, etc.


I can almost smell the smugness.
X-Men: First Class RPG - Welcoming all new players!
[http://s1.zetaboards.com/New_Mutants/index/]

User Info: LunarAmbience

LunarAmbience
4 years ago#40
Almost a wiff of, "I couldn't even bother to watch the entire exchange, but I will carry on about how well WLC did and would have done."
The above is both true and false.
  1. Boards
  2. Religion
  3. WLC Wins Another Debate

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived