This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Spy - Knife vs. Big Earner

#1JackL777Posted 10/7/2012 1:12:39 PM
Knife vs. Big Earner - Results (47 votes)
Knife
89.36% (42 votes)
42
Big Earner
10.64% (5 votes)
5
This poll is now closed.
-Scout-
Scattergun vs. Shortstop - Scattergun
Scattergun vs. Baby Face's Blaster - Scattergun
Force a Nature vs. Soda Popper - Soda Popper
Force a Nature vs. Shortstop - Shortstop
Soda Popper vs. Shortstop - Soda Popper
Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol vs. Winger - Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol
Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol vs. Pistol - Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol
Flying Guillotine vs. Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol - Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol
Flying Guillotine vs. Pistol - Flying Guillotine
Mad Milk vs. Pistol - Pistol
Mad Milk vs. Bonk! Atomic Punch - Mad Milk
Crit-A-Cola vs. Bonk! Atomic Punch - Bonk! Atomic Punch
Crit-A-Cola vs. Mad Milk - Mad Milk
Sandman vs. Bat - Sandman
Sandman vs. Atomizer - Atomizer
Sandman vs. Boston Basher - Sandman
Candy Cane vs. Boston Basher - Candy Cane
Fan O' War vs. Boston Basher - Boston Basher
Fan O' War vs. Wrap Assassin - Fan O' War
Sun-On-A-Stick vs. Wrap Assassin - Wrap Assassin
Holy Mackerel vs. Frying Pan - Holy Mackerel
Holy Mackerel vs. Unarmed Combat - Holy Mackerel
Holy Mackerel vs. Saxxy - Saxxy

-Soldier-
Rocket Launcher vs. Black Box - Rocket Launcher
Rocket Launcher vs. Liberty Launcher - Rocket Launcher
Rocket Launcher vs. Direct Hit - Rocket Launcher
Black Box vs. Liberty Launcher - Black Box
Black Box vs. Beggar's Bazooka - Black Box
Cow Mangler 5000 vs. Beggar's Bazooka - Cow Mangler 5000
Liberty Launcher vs. Beggar's Bazooka - Liberty Launcher
Shotgun vs. Reserve Shooter - Shotgun
Battalion's Backup vs. Concheror - Battalion's Backup
Battalion's Backup vs. Buff Banner - Buff Banner
Shotgun vs. Buff Banner - Shotgun
Mantreads vs. Gunboats - Gunboats
Buff Banner vs. Gunboats - Buff Banner
Battalions Backup vs. Gunboats - Gunboats
Reserve Shooter vs. Concheror - Concheror
Reserve Shooter vs. Righteous Bison - Righteous Bison
Reserve Shooter vs. Mantreads - Reserve Shooter
Shovel vs. Pain Train - Pain Train
Half Zatoichi vs. Pain Train - Pain Train
Half Zatoichi vs. Shovel - Half Zatoichi
Disciplinary Action vs. Pain Train - Disciplinary Action
Disciplinary Action vs. Market Gardener - Disciplinary Action
Disciplinary Action vs. Half Zatoichi - Disciplinary Action
Pain Train vs. Market Gardener - Market Gardener
Equalizer vs. Escape Plan - Escape Plan
Equalizer vs. Pain Train - Equalizer
Equalizer vs. Market Gardener - Market Gardener
Escape Plan vs. Disciplinary Action - Escape Plan

-Pyro-
Flamethrower vs. Degreaser - Degreaser
Flamethrower vs. Backburner - Flamethrower
Phlogistinator vs. Backburner - Backburner
Shotgun vs. Detonator - Shotgun
Shotgun vs. Flare Gun - Flare Gun
Shotgun vs. Reserve Shooter - Shotgun
Detonator vs. Reserve Shooter - Reserve Shooter
Detonator vs. Manmelter - Detonator
Scorch Shot vs. Manmelter - Manmelter
Fire Axe vs. Sharpened Volcano Fragment - Sharpened Volcano Fragment
Third Degree vs. Sharpened Volcano Fragment - Third Dregree
Homewrecker vs. Powerjack - Homewrecker
Homewrecker vs. Backscratcher - Homewrecker
Homewrecker vs. Axtinguisher - Axtinguisher
Postal Pummeler vs. Axtinguisher - Axtinguisher
Powerjack vs. Backscratcher - Powerjack
Powerjack vs. Neon Annihilator - Powerjack
Neon Annihilator vs. Backscratcher - Backscratcher
Neon Annihilator vs. Sharpened Volcano Fragment - Neon Annihilator
---
I am Turaku <-- Steam ID
#2JackL777(Topic Creator)Posted 10/7/2012 1:12:45 PM
-Demoman-
Grenade Launcher vs. Loch-n-Load - Grenade Launcher
Bootlegger vs. Ali Baba's Wee Booties - Bootlegger
Stickybomb Launcher vs. Scottish Resistance - Stickybomb Launcher
Chargin' Targe vs. Splendid Screen - Splendid Screen
Bottle vs. Pain Train - Bottle
Bottle vs. Ullapool Caber - Ullapool Caber
Bottle vs. Half Zatoichi - Half Zatoichi
Scotsman's Skullcutter vs. Half Zatoichi - Half Zatoichi
Scotsman's Skullcutter vs. Claidheamh Mor - Scotsman's Skullcutter
Pain Train vs. Half Zatoichi - Half Zatoichi
Eyelander vs. Persian Persuader - Eyelander
Ullapool Caber vs. Half Zatoichi - Half Zatoichi
Horseless Headless Horsemann's Headtaker vs. Nessie's Nine Iron - Horseless Headless Horsemann's Headtaker

-Heavy-
Minigun vs. Tomislav - Minigun
Minigun vs. Huo-Long Heater - Minigun
Tomislav vs. Huo-Long Heater - Hou-Long Heater
Brass Beast vs. Natasha - Brass Beast
Shotgun vs. Family Business - Shotgun
Shotgun vs. Buffalo Steak Sandvich - Shotgun
Shotgun vs. Sandvich - Sandvich
Buffalo Steak Sandvich vs. Dalokoh's Bar - Buffalo Steak Sandvich
Buffalo Steak Sandvich vs. Family Business - Family Business
Fist vs. Killing Gloves of Boxing - Killing Gloves of Boxing
Fist vs. Warrior's Spirit - Fist
Fist vs. Eviction Notice - Fist
Killing Gloves of boxing vs. Fist of Steel - Fist of Steel
Killing Gloves of Boxing vs. Holiday Punch - Holiday Punch
Eviction Notice vs. Warrior's Spirit - Eviction Notice
Fist of Steel vs. Holiday Punch - Fist Of Steel
Fist of Steel vs. Gloves of Running Urgently - Gloves of Running Urgently

-Engineer-
Shotgun vs. Frontier Justice - Shotgun
Shotgun vs. Widowmaker - Shotgun
Shotgun vs. Pomson 6000 - Pomson 6000
Widowmaker vs. Frontier Justice - Frontier Justice
Pistol vs. Wrangler - Wrangler
Pistol vs. Short Circuit - Pistol
Wrench vs. Jag - Jag
Wrench vs. Eureka Effect - Wrench
Wrench vs. Gunslinger - Wrench
Jag vs. Southern Hospitality - Jag
Eureka Effect vs. Southern Hospitality - Southern Hospitality
Golden Wrench vs. Saxxy - Golden Wrench

-Sniper-
Sniper Rifle vs. Bazaar Bargain - Sniper Rifle
Sniper Rifle vs. Machina - Sniper Rifle
Sniper Rifle vs. Hitman's Heatmaker - Sniper Rifle
Sniper Rifle vs. Huntsman - Sniper Rifle
Bazaar Bargain vs. Machina - Bazaar Bargain
Bazaar Bargain vs. Hitman's Heatmaker - Hitman's Heatmaker
Machina vs. Sydney Sleeper - Machina
Machina vs. Hitman's Heatmaker - Hitman's Heatmaker
Submachine Gun vs. Cleaner's Carbine - Submachine Gun
Submachine Gun vs. Jarate - Jarate
Submachine Gun vs. Cozy Camper - Submachine Gun
Razorback vs. Cozy Camper - Cozy Camper
Razorback vs. Darwin's Danger Shield - Darwin's Danger Shield
Cozy Camper vs. Darwin's Danger Shield - Darwin's Danger Shield
Cleaner's Carbine vs. Darwin's Danger Shield - Cleaner's Carbine
Kukri vs. Shahanshah - Kukri
Kukri vs. Tribalman's Shiv - Tribalman's Shiv
Shahanshah vs. Tribalman's Shiv - Tribalman's Shiv
Bushwacka vs. Tribalamns's Shiv - Bushwacka

-Spy-
Revolver vs. Ambassador - Ambassador
Revolver vs. L'Etranger - Revolver
Revolver vs. Enforcer - Enforcer
Revolver vs. Diamondback - Revolver
L'Etranger vs. Diamondback - L'Etranger
Ambassador vs. Enforcer - Ambassador
Sapper vs. Red-Tape Recorder - Red-Tape Recorder
Knife vs. Conniver's Kunai - Knife
Knife vs. Big Earner -
---
I am Turaku <-- Steam ID
#3JackL777(Topic Creator)Posted 10/7/2012 1:17:31 PM
Actually going with big earner. Why? because most of the time I play spy, the moment I'm caught I'm dead anyway. The cloak on kill can also be useful with the dr. but just my opinion.
---
I am Turaku <-- Steam ID
#4RyusutaPosted 10/7/2012 1:58:26 PM
As much as I love the Big Earner, the Knife is obviously the better choice 99% of the time at least.
---
http://i.imgur.com/cK3Ri.png
#5tiomastaPosted 10/7/2012 2:04:23 PM
JackL777 posted...
Actually going with big earner. Why? because most of the time I play spy, the moment I'm caught I'm dead anyway. The cloak on kill can also be useful with the dr. but just my opinion.


Knife: 17
Big Earner: 1

Hum. There might be something wrong with your reasoning.

100 health instead of 125 is basically kind of a big deal (DAARHAWRH), and you don't simply either "get caught and die" or just never get hit.

25 is a reasonable amount on its own for some part, but lowering that from 125 makes more stuff kill you easier.
*Close-range rockets instantly kill you
*Two little splashes from mid-range rockets still manage to kill you
*Scattergun meatshots instantly kill you, and may reduce one needed hit overall
*Loch grenades and even non-Loch grenades instantly kill you
*Degreaser to flare gun crit instantly kills you, no afterburn needed
*One single sticky on the ground instantly kills you
*Spy revolvers may take one less shot to kill you in general (or if you get non-backstabbed by a failspy, 3 hits will always kill you instead of 4)

Heck, you can even die after getting hit by a Southern Hospitality once. No crit, no minicrit, no random damage spread required.

Not that the Big Earner is completely, totally, absolutely, 100% useless or anything, but I hate when people underrate a notable stat.
---
There are three types of people in the world: people that can count, and people that can't.
"I hate when someone quotes himself in his sig." -Me
#6JackL777(Topic Creator)Posted 10/7/2012 2:14:25 PM
tiomasta posted...
JackL777 posted...
Actually going with big earner. Why? because most of the time I play spy, the moment I'm caught I'm dead anyway. The cloak on kill can also be useful with the dr. but just my opinion.


Knife: 17
Big Earner: 1

Hum. There might be something wrong with your reasoning.

100 health instead of 125 is basically kind of a big deal (DAARHAWRH), and you don't simply either "get caught and die" or just never get hit.

25 is a reasonable amount on its own for some part, but lowering that from 125 makes more stuff kill you easier.
*Close-range rockets instantly kill you
*Two little splashes from mid-range rockets still manage to kill you
*Scattergun meatshots instantly kill you, and may reduce one needed hit overall
*Loch grenades and even non-Loch grenades instantly kill you
*Degreaser to flare gun crit instantly kills you, no afterburn needed
*One single sticky on the ground instantly kills you
*Spy revolvers may take one less shot to kill you in general (or if you get non-backstabbed by a failspy, 3 hits will always kill you instead of 4)

Heck, you can even die after getting hit by a Southern Hospitality once. No crit, no minicrit, no random damage spread required.

Not that the Big Earner is completely, totally, absolutely, 100% useless or anything, but I hate when people underrate a notable stat.


It was just my opinion. not a reasoning to get every to use it :P
---
I am Turaku <-- Steam ID