Is this fair?

  • Topic Archived

User Info: wh0opssuncanned

wh0opssuncanned
9 years ago#1
We were doin kara and we did the opera event and the eternium greathelm dropped (I was one of the tanks) and they automatically gave it to the other tank because he had a PvP helmet and it was a bigger "upgrade" for him because i had the felsteel helm.

User Info: Sanga Vailo

Sanga Vailo
9 years ago#2
not at all
You want to know the meaning of life.

User Info: Mechanic_Jaguar

Mechanic_Jaguar
9 years ago#3
Sounds like you should have gone by the good ol' fashion DKP standard.
"i like to eat apples as i play i find it relaxing and calming and also apples taste pretty good." - Mega Trout

User Info: HaleyJem

HaleyJem
9 years ago#4
I'd say it would depend on who was designated the main tank, whether in this kara group or the guild as a whole. Assuming the kara group is a constant group, meaning the same 10 people run kara every week together, AND you're the MT, you should've gotten the helm. If it was undeclared and/or you're neither the group MT nor the guild MT, I'd say it's fair game.

User Info: R_vs_B_ownz

R_vs_B_ownz
9 years ago#5
ITT he shouldn't get it, if I was the raid leader/master looter I'd tell him to go get something that has defensive stats then come back and tank.
Trolls look pretty stupid too. Their design is too skinny and scrawny, like my genitals ~ flamechampion23

User Info: Iori_Junkie

Iori_Junkie
9 years ago#6
...does your guild normally do things like this?
...were you told to expect things like this?
...will I ever start a sentence with a capital letter?

The answer to number 3 is obviously no.

...but you can answer the other two ;)
They must find it difficult...
Those who have taken authority as truth, rather than truth as authority.
~ Gerald Massey

User Info: R_vs_B_ownz

R_vs_B_ownz
9 years ago#7
IMO* WTB [Edit Button] PST!
Trolls look pretty stupid too. Their design is too skinny and scrawny, like my genitals ~ flamechampion23

User Info: wh0opssuncanned

wh0opssuncanned
9 years ago#8
Ok good because I left the guild right after that.
And in guild info it said we use DKP system.

User Info: Iori_Junkie

Iori_Junkie
9 years ago#9
yeah you got screwed
They must find it difficult...
Those who have taken authority as truth, rather than truth as authority.
~ Gerald Massey

User Info: nights_bane

nights_bane
9 years ago#10
Think of it like this, when your T4 helm drops, it will be a bigger upgrade for you, and hence you will get it. Eternium greathelm isnt even that great, just a bit more hp, but your T4 helm is a massive upgrade.

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived