I had no problem getting moe and mako based on your guide. When I tried to do it myself without a guide, I got moe when I was trying to get mako, which irked me a little (I liked Mako better, and didn't realize she had such a short route...) but when I used the guide I was able to get both of them the way you said.
i didn't follow your guide at first, but i was missing moe's first 3/5 scenario. i then followed your guides for both moe and mako and still don't have it unlocked. it has a cg associated with it too. only thing i have left to unlock :o/