Any game site that randomly assigns a staff member to review a game(99% of gaming journalism) is untrust worthy. There should be a specialist assigned to cover and review each genre and THAT staff member always reviews games for that genre. How am I suppose to know if Tekken Tag 2 is better than Persona 4:Arena if they reviewed by two completely different people despite them both being fighting games? How am I suppose to know if DmC is really a great action game if the same person who reviewed the previous action titles like Bayonetta, DMC4 and so on does not review this one?
In the end trust your own judgment. Do your research, not on reviews, on game content. In the end that's the only way to make a smart purchase.
"If I could use one word to describe you it is Tactless."