Crystal Tin Banishment Catalyst vs Logan Staff?

#1Noob4HirePosted 10/17/2011 1:45:28 PM
I dont quite understand the difference.

Crystal Tin has much lower magic adjust? but it cuts spell use or casting time?

Which one is exactly better?
---
Pokemon White FC: 2021 9085 3628
Standard Rules B/W: Record 38 Win - 36 Loss
#2DuneManPosted 10/17/2011 1:46:39 PM
The crystal one cuts your charges in half... which is bad. Logan's is basically a souped up standard staff. The Int scaling is the other difference. Based on your stats, pick the one you like better.
---
"I'd rather betray the world than let the world betray me." -Cao Cao
#3ShingouryuPosted 10/17/2011 1:47:22 PM
Tin Crystalization Catalyst has higher magic adjust, but cuts your spell charges in half (ie 30 Soul Arrows become 15)

Logan's has a lower magic adjust, but you have normal charges.

So, basically, the Tin Crystalization catalyst is stronger, but at the cost of having less spells to use
---
"Sometimes the bluest parts of the sky seem the farthest away. I guess that's what keeps people striving for it."
#4danny_S_06Posted 10/17/2011 1:47:58 PM
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
#5danny_S_06Posted 10/17/2011 1:49:51 PM
Wait, how do you get the Logon Staff? I assumed the Crystal Tin was the one he used...
---
PSN (UK): CaptainSellers
Currently Playing: Dark Souls
#6Noob4Hire(Topic Creator)Posted 10/17/2011 1:50:08 PM
thanks guys, so crystal better for pvp?
---
Pokemon White FC: 2021 9085 3628
Standard Rules B/W: Record 38 Win - 36 Loss
#7ShingouryuPosted 10/17/2011 1:51:34 PM
danny_S_06 posted...
Wait, how do you get the Logon Staff? I assumed the Crystal Tin was the one he used...

You get the Tin Crystalization Catalyst off his corpse. Logan's Catalyst will be in a chest containing his equipment (sans hat) he leaves where he was before going hollow/insane.
---
"Sometimes the bluest parts of the sky seem the farthest away. I guess that's what keeps people striving for it."
#8ShingouryuPosted 10/17/2011 1:54:16 PM
Noob4Hire posted...
thanks guys, so crystal better for pvp?

If you make those shots count, then yes. If its your first run through, that'd mean you could have a max of 4 soul lances, 2 crystal soul lances, and 5 of each soulmass.

It can also be useful against bosses (especially the 4 kings) if you just need a little more oomph to finish fights quickly.
---
"Sometimes the bluest parts of the sky seem the farthest away. I guess that's what keeps people striving for it."
#9DivineheroPosted 10/17/2011 1:55:49 PM

From: Shingouryu | #007
danny_S_06 posted...
Wait, how do you get the Logon Staff? I assumed the Crystal Tin was the one he used...

You get the Tin Crystalization Catalyst off his corpse. Logan's Catalyst will be in a chest containing his equipment (sans hat) he leaves where he was before going hollow/insane.


eh... how do u trigger him going hollow?
---
Every time I hear "The Big Bang Theory" I imagine God having sex with something and BOOM the Universe was created. - PatrickSim
#10Noob4Hire(Topic Creator)Posted 10/17/2011 2:00:42 PM
Kill Seath and buy all his sorceries and he will go hollow.

I am level50 I beat four kings already. Dont want to level up so I can fight pvp.
---
Pokemon White FC: 2021 9085 3628
Standard Rules B/W: Record 38 Win - 36 Loss