Estoc vs Ricards Rapier

#1BlocktopusPosted 2/15/2012 5:56:38 PM
I know this is a repeated topic, but I've never really used the estoc before (I had it, but it's not here anymore so I guess i'll just get it again when i start NG+).

I'm getting a ton of mixed opinions from people so are there any pros/cons between the two? Which one is better lightning +5?
#2Drago77Posted 2/15/2012 6:28:26 PM
I prefer Estoc because it has longer reach, Ricard's has fancier moves but it requires higher stat investment and for A-scaling in dex it does not have that great of returns.
#3KOTRsssPosted 2/15/2012 6:32:41 PM
On my dex build (40 dex, 28 str), I'm pretty sure that ricard's rapier was outclassed by a normal rapier damage wise by the time they got to +14.
Gamefaqs has taught us that academic fields like literature don't exist because of teenagers that say "well that's just your opinion and I disagree."
#4eclipse_exePosted 2/15/2012 6:35:54 PM
the main reason the ricards rapier is so good is because of its r2 attack, get it with a damage type that isn't 100%blocked by sheilds and watch there hp and stamina drain.
psn: supersoniccd
Havel's ring needs Nerf'd, not DWGR
#5zyrax2301Posted 2/15/2012 6:37:16 PM
The R2 attack is a boss killer but not good for much else.

Estoc > Ricard raper
Why? Because **** you is why.
#6KishinZephritePosted 2/15/2012 7:26:36 PM
Estoc because of the minimal str/dex req, but Ricard's if your build is dex. based.
MW2 3rd prestige 5.5 K/D Youtube-Kishinz
BO 3rd prestige 4.4 K/D PSN: KishinOmega
#7Kratos_Plays_DSPosted 2/15/2012 7:33:47 PM
If it's buffed, I prefer Ricard's. If not, Estoc will do the trick.
'Hi. It's like hello, only shorter.' - Gregory House
#8RPGNinja123Posted 2/15/2012 8:13:43 PM
What a joke this guy plays xbox 360 and says everyone needs to be more helpful yet he posts on PS3 boards.
~The Dark Souls of humanity reside in Blighttown~