BK, Grass Crest, Crest, or Eagle shield?

fisheye11Posted 8/5/2012 4:28:27 PM
these four shields is what i'm choosing over ATM. i just made my way into blight town.(eagle shield obv) i know i should use BK shield for the fire spider.(bad with names) but what about picking a over all shield. i can hold the eagle and still be quick but i just cant decide what to stick with and upgrade. what will work out for me in the long run? if it helps any i'm running a STR/DEX melee build with a +10 claymore and rocking elite knight gear with wolf/"flip" ring.(again bad with names)

so what say you game faqs?
---
This is more fun than chucking rocks at signs!
SolidKnightPosted 8/5/2012 4:29:54 PM
Switch shields on an as-needed basis.
BrockObanaPosted 8/5/2012 4:40:25 PM
GCS for everything except for gimmicky builds
fisheye11(Topic Creator)Posted 8/5/2012 7:09:33 PM
i guess it would be viable to upgrade all of them. i'm not really the type to keep changing gear but i can learn.
---
This is more fun than chucking rocks at signs!
cody316Posted 8/5/2012 7:10:48 PM
I'm personally a fan of the Crest shield. I like parrying, I can't stand taking chip damage from physical attacks, and it's lightweight.

Also, it blocks well against everything except fire. So if you're going to Izalith you can swap it for the BK shield and then go back later.
---
Current Dark Souls Build: Kittysprinkles, Lord of Chaos
PSN: wdh316-=-=-=-=-=-Join the Cult of Cody's Hat Today!
RyoKaibaPosted 8/5/2012 7:15:07 PM
Black Knight Shield is a great PvE shield, particularly for the Fire Defense. Eagle Shield is a pretty newb-friendly Greatshield. I use the Greatshield of Artorias on my Str/Dex build for PvE.
---
"Hate the sin, love the sinner. But sometimes it's hard to look past all that sin and find the person behind it." -Joshua Graham; Fallout: NV
fisheye11(Topic Creator)Posted 8/5/2012 7:24:28 PM
RyoKaiba posted...
Black Knight Shield is a great PvE shield, particularly for the Fire Defense. Eagle Shield is a pretty newb-friendly Greatshield. I use the Greatshield of Artorias on my Str/Dex build for PvE.


i'll keep a look out for that Artorias shield. i normaly block any attack unless i just cant. then i'll dodge. i guess i turtle around most of the time when in battle. and i dont PVP yet. i might make a pvp file after going through the game. so its all PVE for now. i'll keep all this info in mind and upgrade the four shields so i can test them all out to see which is best for my play style.
---
This is more fun than chucking rocks at signs!
LoshadtPosted 8/5/2012 7:26:24 PM
I prefer the Black Knight Shield thanks to its amazing stability and fire defense, and its solid lightning defense. Its biggest issue is that it barely blocks magic, but outside Wrath of God most magic is absurdly easy to dodge.
---
Russian is my first language, so yes there may be a spelling error or two.
I <3 Jesus.
saxrohmerPosted 8/5/2012 7:48:08 PM
If you are blocking in PvP more than 10% of the time, then you are doing it wrong. The GCS is the only mentioned shield that comes with a static bonus even when not in use.

In PvE I use whatever shield fits the situation best.

One shield not mentioned was the heater shield......I love that shield for it's decent block, no chip damage and because it's really light.
---
Do not, under any circumstance, ever use the Sketch command.
PSN: nochildren