Should Replenishment be Allowed in the Fight Club?

  • Topic Archived
  1. Boards
  2. Dark Souls
  3. Should Replenishment be Allowed in the Fight Club?
2 years ago#1
What do You Think? - Results (109 votes)
Yes
76.15% (83 votes)
83
No
23.85% (26 votes)
26
This poll is now closed.
If the majority votes "Yes", then replenishment will be allowed from now on. As a pre-fight body buff and also allowed during fight taken at fighter's own risk. "No" votes win, rules stay as is.
Poll closes 6:00 pm pst today. Results will effect rules immediately.
---
~~~PSN: elfmirfkin~~~
http://youtu.be/Yys59fyPso8
2 years ago#2
was it not already
---
psn: foppehenk, hoekende
http://youtu.be/qfZ6PLvzlVg
2 years ago#3
foppehenk posted...
was it not already


No it wasn't. It caused problems awhile ago so it was banned.
Some people think it is allowed which has caused problems as well. Those disputes were minor so I always just left it up to the chat to decide at the time. This voting will clear it up and make it official.

I personally voted yes. I actually don't care either way. I probably won't use it and don't care if my opponent does. I come to the fight club to have fun and hang out with you guys. So if everyone is happy, I'm happy.
I don't really see it giving much of an advantage if any at all. It takes up your body buff and an attunement slot.
Ftw belongs to all of us, so we will decide together.
---
~~~PSN: elfmirfkin~~~
http://youtu.be/Yys59fyPso8
2 years ago#4
No. No redos. (Healing)
---
Nebraska Cornhuskers
PSN: BOMBAYNUGZ420
2 years ago#5
elfmirfkinn posted...
foppehenk posted...
was it not already


No it wasn't. It caused problems awhile ago so it was banned.
Some people think it is allowed which has caused problems as well.

Well No healing during a fight doesn't = banned replenishment.
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/606312-dark-souls/68035115

Anyway, No. Bans should be limited to ridiculously broken stuff, Replen is fine.
---
PSN: Cronotis
2 years ago#6
It's a wasted spell slot and the other person will just go on the defensive until it wears off or enough time has elapsed to render it useless. By all means, gimp yourself by using it.
2 years ago#7
In my opinion it's only viable with 2 synergy rings nearby anyways.
---
Duelling sporadically. PSN: Lollershopper
2 years ago#8
KDTProjekt posted...
It's a wasted spell slot and the other person will just go on the defensive until it wears off or enough time has elapsed to render it useless. By all means, gimp yourself by using it.

---
psn- CHAON101 - 106
2 years ago#9
Lol why shouldn't it be?
---
Please assume the position.
2 years ago#10
I don't think so. Healing shouldnt be allowed at all. Sure its not strong but it the principal of the matter. Same thing with Sanctus.
---
GT: YusukeUrammeshi or BrokenMessiah
PSN: BrokenMessiah1
  1. Boards
  2. Dark Souls
  3. Should Replenishment be Allowed in the Fight Club?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived