Should Konami invent a 3rd graveyard?

  • Topic Archived
3 years ago#1
Besides the original graveyard most duelist treat the banish/remove from play pile as a 2nd graveyard yet the cards there are not truly removed from the game. There are cards that could either gain power from monster's that are banished or simply make it easier to summon from that pile. With that said should there be a 3rd graveyard, a pile made that makes any cards that enter it truly banished/removed for the rest of the duel and have absolutly no bonus from it?

Opinions?
---
It all starts with this, a jewel containing the ultimate power.
-Shadow the Hedgehog
3 years ago#2
Easy solution: Cards that are banished face-down are blocked off except from cards that can target ANY banished card, and not just monsters.
---
Dueling Network Administrator
3DS FC: 0516 7371 8875
3 years ago#3
That was original planned when "D.D. Warrior" was created. That has since changing into flexible "Banished Zone" that can return as many times as possible.
---
I used to writing a signature like you, till I took a bullet in the knuckle. ~Random signer.
3 years ago#4
Removed from removed from play. There is no zone for it, you just place the cards in your deckcase for the rest of the duel.
---
The Offical Groudon Oof the POkemon Black and White 2 Boards.
3 years ago#5
Doesn't Grave Digger Ghoul still prohibit the card from reentering the game?
3 years ago#6
FuzzyJello posted...
Doesn't Grave Digger Ghoul still prohibit the card from reentering the game?


Nope. They errata'd the card when LOB got a reprint in Legendary Collection 1.

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Errata:Gravedigger_Ghoul
---
Apparently, I'm Nomura now. Not quite sure how that happened. *laughs*
Official Zexion & Xomg of ALL boards
3 years ago#7
rikudo_sennin posted...
FuzzyJello posted...
Doesn't Grave Digger Ghoul still prohibit the card from reentering the game?


Nope. They errata'd the card when LOB got a reprint in Legendary Collection 1.

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Errata:Gravedigger_Ghoul


I expected as much. Wondering if Konami wouldn't catch it and the card would suddenly take on a new value.
3 years ago#8
Note that Banished is a "state" and not a zone.

You can keep your banished cards anywhere you want, in any order, in any pattern.
---
Dueling Network Administrator
3DS FC: 0516 7371 8875
3 years ago#9
It would be funny (but broken) if they allowed you to bring in cards to play from the side deck like Magic did.
---
"With kindness comes naivete. Courage becomes foolhardiness. And dedication has no reward..."
3 years ago#10
TTuvillo posted...
Note that Banished is a "state" and not a zone.

You can keep your banished cards anywhere you want, in any order, in any pattern.


Still with the right cards in play that "state" can be manipulated to the user's benefit which can be frightening to some duelist. They really should have a zone of no return to counter this.
---
It all starts with this, a jewel containing the ultimate power.
-Shadow the Hedgehog

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived