GTthunder posted... should i start over if i want only 1 or the other??
Sigh. Why do you keep asking questions that begin with "Should I..."? You know perfectly well that everything you can do in this game derives from YOUR choices. YOU choose whether to restart or to keep playing. YOU choose whether or not to use magic. YOU choose what guilds to join. YOU choose how you play the goddamn game.
Why is that so hard for you to understand?
Finding the Fiji Mermaid is like playing Calvinball. You can never do it the same way twice. Use the search function before asking questions!