Buy them at the general store. Once you can, craft saddle bags, then you can replenish items from any horse. --- PSN: Duragon_Mikado kabuki....isnt that were you ...you know...on the girl? - CrusaderZeRo
General Store, Crafting, Wagon Traders, and dead bodies.
Remember, if you loot the corpse of someone you kill with an arrow, you get your arrow back. It can also happen for rope darts, but that seems to happen much less often. Maybe if you don't use them as a counter, idk. --- PSN: Rectal_Fungi The fungus is among us