The end of AC2, everything during and after the talking with Minerva. I said "What the ****?!" at almost the exact same time as Desmond.
And also in AC2, doing The Truth videos. They were legitimately creepy, and the one where 16 talks about going to the opera will always be one of the most freaky / scary moments I have ever had in video games.
So how about you guys? --- Marceline, MY Vampire Queen --> http://tinyurl.com/bzlf5fo
Revelations had some neat moments, but i wasn't really Immersed. --- The best plans are the ones that don't work unless you wing it along the way. -Skandrae Support Project Crystallis! http://projectcrystallis.org/
ACI; Altair getting reduced to Novice and having to work back up. Al Mualim's speech was great... the first time. :P
ACII; opening the vault, letting Borgia live with his failure.
AssBro; the intro, flashing through Ezio losing his hidden blade in battle, then seeing it all play out at the end - send Cesare on his date with gravity :D
AssRev; Ezio deciding he had seen enough and ditching his weapons and armor.
ACIII; Connor going home to find some random camper where his people used to live, and told that the land was bought. It was all for nothing. --- Oh no, there goes Toh-kee-yoh! http://www.rockband.com/users/Dark_Raven_X