Assassins Creed or Red Dead Redemption - Which has better hunting?

#41ish0turfac3Posted 11/5/2012 12:44:42 PM
bearded_moose posted...
anyone responding rationally to ish0t is just feeding the troll.

Yeah having a opinion makes me a troll... so sorry lololol.
GT: ish0turfac3
Please tell me more while I'm sitting over here in my corner eating popcorn not giving a crap about your opinion.
#42HighOnPhazonPosted 11/5/2012 12:54:45 PM
RDR, no contest.
GT: AncientToaster
Speak of the devil...and he shall appear
#43the_arisenPosted 11/5/2012 12:57:01 PM
Honestly I cant believe you guys are arguing over which has the more realistic hunting... Honestly neither of these games are that realistic when it comes to hunting.... this arguement is akin to having an argument over which is closer to the color blue - red or orange
GT- Valo Drake
#44Homie_202Posted 11/5/2012 12:57:50 PM
AC3 by a mile the RDR hunting wasn't even that great. Like another poster said it was just you see an animal and you shoot it in this you can track an animal, hunt them from the trees bait them and use snares to catche them there is way more to this games hunting.
#45EllesarienPosted 11/5/2012 1:18:27 PM
Until I get chased by a Cougar, run up a tree to a branch, and then jump out of said tree and assassinate the Cougar in RDR...Well...It's AC3.
I will try and see it from your point of view, but I doubt we'll be able to fit both our heads up there.
#46redhotpeppersPosted 11/5/2012 1:34:22 PM
AC3,although I am not a fan of the qte's and I think that the hunting would have been better without them.
#47Gobey6Posted 11/5/2012 1:39:07 PM
AC3 has cooler utilization of baiting, tracking, snaring, and generally sneaking up on animals than RDR. But i still usually end up just running and knifing any animals... But the QTE's kind of make fighting deadly animals lame... Only wolves can really be an issue if you mess up the button press... Sure in RDR you have guns but cougars wolves and bears could still be a threat... And if I killed one with my knife I felt accomplished in RDR... Not so in AC3

But at least in AC3 you can skip the skinning animations..
"You're never too young to have a Vietnam flashback." --- Gamertag: Gobey6
#48TakuruPosted 11/5/2012 1:41:51 PM
Red Dead by a mile. I don't even know how you can even think that AC3 is better in this area.
#49thisawesomedudePosted 11/5/2012 1:57:00 PM
bish0p2004 posted...
ish0turfac3 posted...
Red dead redemption by a mile. All of those reason given as to why ac3 hunting is better are just stupid as hell.

It's even more stupid that there are no reasons given as to why RDR has better hunting.

I prefer AC3 over RDR no I don't hate RDR either but being PA hunter the whole environment hits home to me.
The choice between traps, the bow, weather, skinning and trying for perfect pelts. I believe they laid a good foundation for a better hunting system.
Wolfman Jack says this is a signature baby!
#50LogicmongerPosted 11/5/2012 1:57:51 PM
Gobey6 posted...
... But at least in AC3 you can skip the skinning animations..