i've heard I need to give this to her for some reason maybe, and when I give it to her, it doesn't say "Item cannot be used now." It simply closes out of the menu as if she took it, but no dialogue appears and I don't lose the item.
It does the same thing with the "Right Half." Am I screwed? o_O (This is a 1st Playthrough, Modified Route if that matters any.)
"The best things in life must be taken by force!" ~Captain Khan