Wii U

Likes:
-the controller is cool. I always loved GBA-GC connected games. This will bring cool ideas.
-play separate from the TV, a bonus to kids and husbands.

Dislikes:
-The only differentiation is the touch screen controller. I was expecting new online ideas like Onlive for Nintendo. I was expecting the ability to take the controller with you. All the third party games are on PS360 so they mean very little to me.
-No First Party games shown. My fears are confirmed; Nintendo has a lot of catching up to do to match the HD era. Third parties are already there, so thats what we saw.

Ho-Hum:
-Graphics. Nothing looked better than PS3. For that matter, nothing looked better than Uncharted 3 at all of E3. At least Nintendo has caught up with the competition though, graphics wise.
-No price announced, which has me weary.

Overall it's cool, but I was hoping for so much more. All I can see is a PS3 with a touch screen controller and worse online features. Of course it will have Nintendo first party games but Nintendo is 5 years behind the other developers so I'm not expecting anything revolutionary for quite some time. I need to know more!!!

From: Natureboy99 | #001
-No price announced, which has me weary.

That controller alone is going to spike the price by a good deal; I'm expecting a very unappealing price tag announcement next year.

Also, the fact is, I see no reason to buy this over PS3/360, outside of playing Mario, and a Zelda game 4 years down the road. I guess I really just don't see the point in this system existing.