From: BrokenBandit84 | #003
It IS just a art direction. Developers don't put in the realistic Nitty gritty dark look because they have "Lighting issues". They do it because the stupid American gaming audience inexplicably likes that sort of garbage.
I'd say it certainly was an art direction - but some games have utilized it for lighting concerns (either exclusively for that reason or just as a bit of a bonus to them).
P.s. - funny quote XD
---
"The next statement is true. The previous statement was false."
~ Stephen Colbert