Should Miyamoto direct persona 5?

#1soarcadiaPosted 7/29/2013 11:04:00 AM
I'm curious what he would do with it.
---
Skies of arcadia>>>>>>>>>>> final fantasy 7
#2HayashiTakaraPosted 7/29/2013 11:08:53 AM
Will never work, Miyamoto is all about gameplay and it's mechanics, he doesn't specialize in story.
#3oskman888Posted 7/29/2013 11:18:51 AM
Hell no. I don't want him anywhere near Persona 5.
---
pants
#4soarcadia(Topic Creator)Posted 7/29/2013 11:19:10 AM
HayashiTakara posted...
Will never work, Miyamoto is all about gameplay and it's mechanics, he doesn't specialize in story.


But he could improve the gameplay.
---
Skies of arcadia>>>>>>>>>>> final fantasy 7
#5NovaeGamerPosted 7/29/2013 11:35:31 AM
soarcadia posted...
HayashiTakara posted...
Will never work, Miyamoto is all about gameplay and it's mechanics, he doesn't specialize in story.


But he could improve the gameplay.


Unlikely. JRPGs aren't about the "direct fun through gameplay"-stuff that Miyamoto excels at; There is a completely different philosophy behind the "fun" of JRPGs, which, even though Miyamoto maybe understands it in its basics, he is not suited for designing it.
#6The_DjokerPosted 7/29/2013 11:39:34 AM
HayashiTakara posted...
Will never work, Miyamoto is all about gameplay and it's mechanics, he doesn't specialize in story.


You act like Miyamoto has done anything of any significance in the last 10 years. Apart from Mario galaxy, he's done bugger all since 2002 with Pikmin. Nothing but rehashes and recycled ideas.
---
http://s19.postimage.org/aosug5mrn/Persona4.png
#7chareyPosted 7/29/2013 11:44:55 AM
No, Miyamoto makes good games but story, the main draw of JRPGs, is his weak point in design. It just doesn't fit him.
---
I won't have it! I'm not having anyone talk about me in
the past tense! ~Squall Leonhart
#8SlimeSwayzePosted 7/29/2013 11:51:54 AM
Would you hire an electrician to fix your toilet (unless of course you have an electric toilet)? Why ruin a new entry in an established series by handing it to someone who doesn't seem to know or care about the genre?
---
Currently Playing: Too many to report.
#9Lord_KagatoPosted 7/29/2013 12:06:29 PM
I'd much rather Atlus keep control over directing Persona 5. They're doing a great job already.
---
Watch my LPs and UMvC3's Courtroom Drama! - http://tinyurl.com/bo7nxnx
Current LPs: Injustice, Tomb Raider 2013, Persona 3 FES
#10soarcadia(Topic Creator)Posted 7/29/2013 12:26:05 PM
The_Djoker posted...
HayashiTakara posted...
Will never work, Miyamoto is all about gameplay and it's mechanics, he doesn't specialize in story.


You act like Miyamoto has done anything of any significance in the last 10 years. Apart from Mario galaxy, he's done bugger all since 2002 with Pikmin. Nothing but rehashes and recycled ideas.


As if you know what he did.
---
Skies of arcadia>>>>>>>>>>> final fantasy 7