Mario 3D World vs. New Super Mario U vs. Mario Galaxy?

#1DragonQuestFanPosted 12/26/2013 7:47:26 PM
I played Galaxy 1 (not Galaxy 2), and although I liked it, it didn't fire me up. How would you compare the two Wii U Marios (or even Galaxy 2) to the first Galaxy?
Most Wanted: Dragon Quest VII 3DS-Lords of Shadow 2-Dragon Age III-The Witcher 3-Star Trek: Deep Space Nine on Blu-Ray!!
#2Puckswack12Posted 12/26/2013 7:49:33 PM
Galaxy is arguably the best game ever so..

3d world is very good

But it's no galaxy
#3DarkHeroZXPosted 12/26/2013 8:04:00 PM(edited)
Galaxy 1+2 are insanely good.

3D world is great but yeah not as good as Galaxy

Mario U is par for the course. Not bad but absolutely nothing noteworthy
"I do a lot of push ups and sit-ups and I drink plenty of juice"-Vegeta
#4picanoPosted 12/26/2013 8:08:24 PM(edited)
I personally liked 3D World better than Galaxy. Galaxy was great but, had solid level design, and a great (and non-intrusive) story... but being able to play 3D World with friends makes it my favorite.

NSMBU was decent, but nothing to really stand out like the 3D games.

3D and catgirls! :
#5lowuwPosted 12/26/2013 8:07:48 PM
3D World a lot more fun for me than the Galaxy games. It has better level variety and way better powerups.
#6manmousePosted 12/26/2013 8:09:48 PM
i prefer 3D World over Galaxy.

Galaxy has a more impressive world and visuals, and its physics and level design feel much more fresh than any other Mario.

but 3DWorld has faster paced gameplay, more variety in characters/skills, more interesting powerups (Galaxy's are mostly one-trick ponies meant for specific duties and useless everywhere else, whereas 3DWorld's bring unique approaches to each level in which you use them), and more tight platforming.
#7JKSonicPosted 12/26/2013 8:22:01 PM
For me so far...

3D Land > 3D World >>> Galaxy(s) >>>>>>>>>> New SMB U
--- (pinup and boudoir) (families, scenery, etc)
#8Devilman_AmonPosted 12/27/2013 11:32:13 AM
My friends 5 yr old son got really frustrated yesterday playing NSMBU yesterday when we had it on three player. He kept dying from falling off the platforms and generally being confused who he was since the characters are so small. Then we played the co-op 2 player story mode for Smash Bros Brawl and he had a better time.

Is Mario World 3D World easier for kids? or Galaxy?
#9GiygasminionPosted 12/27/2013 12:00:45 PM
Super Mario Galaxy=Super Mario Galaxy 2>Super Mario 3d World> New Super Mario Bros. U
NN ID: Achilles11 3DS FC: 0860-3339-6889
#10Too_many_namesPosted 12/27/2013 12:03:54 PM
Mario Galaxy > Mario 3D World >> New Super Mario Bros U
An old man once told me: "No old man is to be trusted".