Why do people want Mario Galaxy 3?

#1iKhan88Posted 3/4/2014 9:18:49 PM
This seriously perplexes me. Over the past few years the Mario franchise has been sequel milked to death, and while I'm certainly confident EAD Tokyo can make original levels for Galaxy 3, and that it can be an amazing game, it's time to explore new territory.

Consider what Miyamoto said about Nintendo making new IPs. He said that they have a gameplay idea, then they only make a new franchise if one of their other franchises fit that game idea. I totally respect that, but making something like Mario Galaxy 3 ISN'T a new idea, it's an old general idea with new levels with a mix of old and new.

It's time for Mario to go somewhere else. Super Mario Jungle maybe. Or Super Mario Net (as in internet). That would give us opportunities to get not an actual sequel to Galaxy, but a game that is amazing for the same perfect originality for which Galaxy was amazing.
---
"That does not excuse the things we have done. It is merely a motive, not a justification" --Kratos Aurion
#2lp913Posted 3/4/2014 9:23:55 PM
Because the first two were fantastic, inspiring, creative, critically acclaimed GOTY contending full 3D Platformers?
---
[NNID: LPLETHAL79]
[3DS FC: 0645-5794-3020]
#3BrownbearbobPosted 3/4/2014 9:24:38 PM
I completely agree.I have no idea why people constantly request it.
---
3DSFC: 0430-8332-4765
AC:NL - Blaise from Mars
#4higgsboson1997Posted 3/4/2014 9:32:57 PM
lp913 posted...
Because the first two were fantastic, inspiring, creative, critically acclaimed GOTY contending full 3D Platformers?


Yeah, and so was SM3DW.
A new creative one will be extremely refreshing for the franchise.
#5Mandrew257Posted 3/4/2014 9:34:57 PM
I'd rather have another Sunshine instead of another Galaxy.
---
FOOLISH YOUTH...the soil knows all - Rolf
PSN/NNID: Mandrew257
#6SeamusOHasseyPosted 3/4/2014 9:35:02 PM
It's funny how people criticize Galaxy for being too similar and not introducing new ideas, yet people complained about Paper Mario SS not being like TTYD and PM. Just saying.
---
You're not funny and nobody likes you.
I shouldn't have to press [1] for English in the US. Just saying.
#7iKhan88(Topic Creator)Posted 3/4/2014 9:38:02 PM
SeamusOHassey posted...
It's funny how people criticize Galaxy for being too similar and not introducing new ideas, yet people complained about Paper Mario SS not being like TTYD and PM. Just saying.


I'm not criticizing the Galaxies or 3D Land/World for being too similar. EAD Tokyo has done a fantastic job of avoiding that. However, there is only so much you can do in a single world. To put it another way, you can't recreate the magic of first playing Galaxy within the Galaxy series.
---
"That does not excuse the things we have done. It is merely a motive, not a justification" --Kratos Aurion
#8Ritster21Posted 3/4/2014 10:04:21 PM
People want a "proper" 3D Mario game.

I agree with them.
---
FC is 4038-6283-8425
#9iKhan88(Topic Creator)Posted 3/4/2014 10:28:52 PM
Ritster21 posted...
People want a "proper" 3D Mario game.

I agree with them.


I do too. That doesn't necessarily mean Galaxy 3. It didn't mean Sunshine 2 in the Wii era, and it didn't mean Mario 64 2 in the GC era.
---
"That does not excuse the things we have done. It is merely a motive, not a justification" --Kratos Aurion
#10Stanger5150Posted 3/4/2014 10:32:06 PM
Ritster21 posted...
People want a "proper" 3D Mario game.

I agree with them.


I've yet to see a good argument explaining how 3D World isn't a "proper" 3D Mario.
---
PSN/NN- BlackRain8782
2600, NES, SMS, GB, Lynx, Genesis, TG-16, SNES, Game Gear, Jaguar, PS1, Saturn, N64, GBC, DC, PS2, GCN, GBA, DS, Wii, PS3, 3DS, Wii U