Question.....

Back To: Board List | Topic List | Topic Archived
First | Previous | Page 3 of 3
VectorChaos
Posted 10/20/2011 3:45:08 PM
Born_Stellar posted...
Are you sure theyre both considered canon? because what ive heard is that bungie has stated that the games are canon, and the books are not

Games are canon, books are canon, a whole lot of things are canon, but when two sources are in conflict, game canon > book canon.
---
PSN: VectorChaos || WTF || XBL: Vector Chaos
Watching Humanity doom itself with a smile since 1984.
devil mingy
Posted 10/27/2011 9:48:29 PM
If you all want to know the fate of Halsey, Mendez, and the Spartans on Onyx, pick up the latest Halo novel, Glasslands.

There's a lot of... interesting developments.

It's not too bad of a novel, either. Traviss has come a long way since her Boba Fett worship days.
---
Got a Halo story question?
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/632877-halo-4/59577580
Born_Stellar
Posted 10/28/2011 8:11:56 AM
I won't get mine 'til the 10th of november... stupid amazon...
knickernoob
Posted 11/8/2011 5:24:25 PM
These are my thoughts simply regarding how cortana gets onto the pillar of autumn. I've only played the games and i haven't read a single word out of the books kudos to you readers out there but i prefer some russian lit but i digress cortana was delivered off planet on a pelican and then taken to the autumn who could still be fighting in outerspace.
That's my theory i don't know for certain if pelicans can reach orbit though.

Did you know space is the same stuff as outerspace. Space being the area between atomic particles. Eerie, thanks to NOVA by the way.
---
I know what I want to do in life. I either want to kill roaches all day, or be an exterminator.
Born_Stellar
Posted 11/8/2011 6:17:53 PM

[QUOTE="knickernoob"]These are my thoughts simply regarding how cortana gets onto the pillar of autumn. I've only played the games and i haven't read a single word out of the books kudos to you readers out there but i prefer some russian lit but i digress cortana was delivered off planet on a pelican and then taken to the autumn who could still be fighting in outerspace.

That would have been a better way of executing Reach's storyline, unfortunately the geniuses at bungie clearly didnt agree (lets hope they at least thought of it). what is also unfortunate about your suggestion is that this can't correspond with what happened in the books, since the autumn was in fact NEVER planetside. Bungie has effectively ruined the Autumn's presence in the outerspace battle around reach, since there is simply no time for the autumn to have landed on reach, when looking at the book's timeline.

The only reason i can come up with as to why they chose to write reach's storyline the way they did was to make sure that captain keyes had a live appearance in the game. although, personally, a direct video transmition to some shuttle/ship that could have acted as a transport medium for the latchkey discovery would have been just as good. then the game wouldn't have had to so recklessly render a perfectly valid and arguably MUCH better story obsolete. also, it wouldnt require a tedious reconciliation effort between Nylund's and Bungie's story (aka the data drops).


That's my theory i don't know for certain if pelicans can reach orbit though.

in fact they can, seeing as johnson and the rest managed to escape halo in one. theyre also very suitable for outerspace travel. all they really lack is an FTL drive.


Jump to Page: 1  2  3  
First | Previous | Page 3 of 3