They reason why I would put Halo 2 so high is because of the memories, before halo 2 there was no console game like it as far as the multiplayer was concerned, I remember walking 3 miles to toys r us for the midnight release to get it and played it from 1am to 4pm before going into a coma. Halo 4 is looking to be that type of game for me again.
Opinion are like belly buttons, everyone's got one, and not all are the same. Who cares? It's the dude's opinion.
When you play 4 though, you realize Bungie made a **** Halo game and was an awful way for them to finish their name with the Brand. --- XBL GT Haoh Gadoken Currently Enjoying: Pokemon LeafGreen, DKC2, LoL