I think this is a decent roster. It has some characters I want, and didn't cut anyone I really care about. There's none that really blow me away (Though Shulk and Bayonetta come very close).
Also I really don't think it's fair to consider Bayonetta a Sega rep. I'd say she's a Platinum rep, and especially since Nintendo are the ones really trying to help with her games as of late, not really Sega. Was she in Sonic and Sega All Star Racing and Transformed? No, and that's a sega game. But I think she's in W101 and that's a pure Platinum game.
Yet there's a disclaimer in the credits saying Sega owns her. But here on GameFAQS we just "HURR DURR I LIEK DIS CHARACTER SO DEY ARE LIKELY ISH MY OPINION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111111" --- Official Sonic of the Super Smash Bros. for Wii U board 3DS FC: 0447-5534-8311
I feel like there are too many third party characters, and that Bayonetta really shouldn't be in. What distinguishes her above other third party guests other than her sequel being Wii U exclusive? That's really not enough.
Otherwise I feel like the newcomer amount is a little on the short side, though that may not be entirely your fault.
I guess overall it's okay though. Maybe get rid of Bayonetta. --- Remember, don't take video games too seriously- Plenty of GameFAQs users will do that for you. -Official Kira of GameFAQs-
Stupid snake is in it which sucks but those two ladies make up for it! :D --- Homosexual Hipster of Smash Bros and Pokemon X and Y boards. G.A.Y = Good At Yugioh. Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/xyzlactic
The only one I don't like is Bayonetta. Other than that I think it's fantastic. Nicely done. --- Battletoads, Killer Instinct, GoldenEye, Perfect Dark, Jet Force Gemini, DK Country, Diddy Racing, Banjo, Conker. Rare, you will be missed.