Rate this roster/10

#11SenselessBreakPosted 1/21/2014 4:58:22 PM
-Waluigi
-Paper Mario
+ K Rool
++Palutena
+Ridley
---Robin (Over Chrom)
+Takamaru
+Little Mac
-Layton

7/10
---
Senselez from Breakvil
2320 6273 4643
#12ragnarok183Posted 1/21/2014 5:14:32 PM
2/10

my thoughts (pro's, neutral's, con's)...

+palutena (tbh, she's the only addition i wholly agree with here)

~who's takamaru?
~recycled entirety of brawl's roster, in addition to all the confirmed characters thus far
~i'm not crazy about l.mac or isaac, or some of the other speculated newcomers
~wtf is with mewtwo's and zelda's pic?

-overabundance of mario reps
-toon link (to be fair, my "ideal" roster can no longer be "perfect" now that he's confirmed)
-paper mario (especially if he's too similar to the original, like toon link already is)
-some rather random choices (layton?)
-ice climbers, snake, and meta knight--mainly if they're as dysfunctional as they were in brawl
-rob (still seems more of a "joke" character than not, imo; i don't want rob returning)
-bland pokemon reps (i actually kinda don't want to see lucario return--especially if mewtwo's in this roster)
-robin? really?
-so many fire emblem characters have so much potential in smash bros; i would've liked more
#13TheAquaman803Posted 1/21/2014 5:16:07 PM
Has Waluigi. Ten out of ten even though the rest sucks.
---
3DS FC: 2208-5387-4927
SSBB FC: 2020-5299-7105
#14xgiraffes13xPosted 1/21/2014 6:58:18 PM
7.75/10
---
Once a giraffe, always a giraffe.
http://i.imgur.com/8BYWIuv.png
#15_Intarwebz_Posted 1/21/2014 7:16:46 PM
It's a pretty realistic roster with the exception of Layton and Paper Mario. This board is going to be SO disappointed with the final roster. Expect tons of raging and overreactions.
#16ultimategamer_1Posted 1/21/2014 7:41:45 PM
This is mine
file:///C:/Users/Chris%20H/Pictures/3DS%20Roster.png
#17Austin_4ePosted 1/21/2014 7:46:06 PM
Roster time? Roster time.

http://i.imgur.com/HjmWoL2.png
---
http://i.imgur.com/BNZWG.gif | http://i.imgur.com/Qh8jO.gif | http://i.imgur.com/QwY3n.gif
[[ PSN / WiiU / Steam: Austin_4e ]]
#18GameNinjaGuyPosted 1/21/2014 7:49:03 PM
8/10
Not a big fan of Paper Mario or Waluigi, but everything else is okay and not too ridiculous. Might be a bit big possibly but I dont really know there.
---
I don't suffer from insanity; I enjoy every minute of it!
#19Forsoothious(Topic Creator)Posted 1/21/2014 7:56:12 PM
Thanks for responding, guys! I'll take note of everything you've said and probably try to make a roster again at some point with those things in mind.
#20ragnarok183Posted 1/21/2014 11:52:30 PM
Austin_4e posted...
Roster time? Roster time.

http://i.imgur.com/HjmWoL2.png


1/10

my thoughts (pro's, neutral's, con's, and con's among con's)...

+palutena
+chrom

~who's takamaru?
~recycled majority of brawl's roster, in addition to all the confirmed characters thus far
~i'm not crazy about l.mac, or some of the other speculated newcomers

-bowser jr. and blaziken...why?
-i'm doubtful about pacman...this ain't sfxt
-toon link (yes i know he's inevitable at this point)
-lucario (especially if mewtwo's in)
-ice climbers, snake, and meta knight--mainly if they're as dysfunctional as they were in brawl
-rob (still seems more of a "joke" character than not, imo; i don't want rob returning)
-mr.g&w axed
-no zss (even if she's intended to be implied in this roster, if samus' transitions were as impractical as they were in brawl, this is still a negative)
-so many fire emblem characters have so much potential in smash bros; i would've liked more

--ffs, more toon's...