Aside from it being bigger than remotely likely, pretty solid. 9/10.
Feel Ridley makes a better boss, even though I know I'm alone in thinking that, and hesitant about Louie and Paper Mario, but otherwise sure.
Yeah, the funny thing is, I wasn't think about the end size as much as I was thinking about the amount of newcomers for it. I got a bit carried away trying to match Brawl's Newcomer size, ehehe. --- Hora Hora Hora~
Villager Mega Man Wii Fit Trainer Rosalina & Luma Little Mac Palutena +1 sure
Chibi-Robo +1 fine
Dixie Kong + also fine
Tingle ehh, not my fav but not a bad choice. Other Zelda characters play a bigger role in their own series.
Ridley +1 Good
Insert Whatever Fire Emblem Rep You Want Here (I know barely anything about that series, and I won't pretend like I do, so, I'm sorry.) +0.5 for not actually picking. Tiki it is though.
Takamaru +1 he's okay.
Mii -1 Against. Miis will either be Villager 2.0 (random objects and such) making them lose their originality or be customizable taking a large part of dev time.
Louie -1 Pikmin shouldn't exactly have two reps. It could, but all the captains are basically the same you might as well just have one.
Tom Nook -0.5 adding two joke characters from the same series comes off as a bit redundant. Villager represents AC perfectly.
Excitebiker -1 two retros in one game is a bit redundant but Exitebiker I don't feel is a very interesting choice. Besides, Sakurai already left him out before, so I think it would be better just to move on.
Paper Mario (Repping His Own Series.) -1. Not a fan of duplicate characters. Even if he had a unique moveset, I would much rather have actual new characters. A stage would be amazing though.
6/10 but I'll add a point for no ridiculous fan wants.
7/10. --- I forgot my clever signature, so I'm back to this.
0/10. Sorry. Replace P.Mario with him and it's a 10. --- 3DS Friend Code: 5000-1894-6879 No, I do NOT like sushi in cake. I mistook the kawaii icons for sushi icons. And I liked the cake one. SushiCake. qq