POLL: Rate my new roster, where I made no cuts (PIC INSIDE)

#1liveman789Posted 1/25/2013 8:47:00 PM
What would you rate this roster? - Results (78 votes)
10/10
6.41% (5 votes)
5
9/10
16.67% (13 votes)
13
8/10
20.51% (16 votes)
16
7/10
14.1% (11 votes)
11
6/10
8.97% (7 votes)
7
5/10
8.97% (7 votes)
7
4/10
7.69% (6 votes)
6
3/10
2.56% (2 votes)
2
2/10
0% (0 votes)
0
1/10
14.1% (11 votes)
11
This poll is now closed.
PICTURE: http://oi48.tinypic.com/20rveif.jpg

TOTAL CHARACTERS: 45 (49 with Transformations)

TOTAL NEWCOMERS: 10
- Bowser Jr.
- Ghirahim
- 6th Generation Pokemon
- Chrom
- King K. Rool
- Palutena
- Takamaru
- Little Mac
- Shulk
- Pac-man


Let me know what you think. This is my best attempt at making a roster without cuts, and without making it too many characters. 45(49) in the peak, in my opinion. A Random Space can be implemented some other way.
#2MM125Posted 1/25/2013 8:50:17 PM
NeedsIsaac/10
---
Oooh, MM, he be tryin' you, dawg. He be tryin' you. Best mind you biiiiiiiz-ness. ~KMA
*triple z snap* ~AluminumTicket
#3Majora999Posted 1/25/2013 8:50:30 PM
Aside from no Hades, it's just about perfect.
---
Not changing sig until Gamefreak brings back R/S/E Secret Bases ~ 2/20/11
#4UberPyro64Posted 1/25/2013 8:50:53 PM
Good roster.

New Mario and Zelda reps are iffy but excusable.

9/10.
---
My SSB4 Roster: http://imageshack.us/a/img543/3938/potentialsmashreps3rost.png
#5liveman789(Topic Creator)Posted 1/25/2013 8:55:37 PM
MM125 posted...
NeedsIsaac/10


I suppose if Golden Sun had a rep, it would be him. I'm not saying he's impossible, but I wouldn't assume they'd get a rep due to their "small" success and popularity.

UberPyro64 posted...
Good roster.

New Mario and Zelda reps are iffy but excusable.

9/10.


It's between them or Toad and Tingle, in my opinion. And those two are silly characters who don't have as much moveset potential as the other two.

majora999 posted...
Aside from no Hades, it's just about perfect.


I'd actually rather Hades, but I think Palutena is more likely.


NOTE: I tried my best to have all the villains on the bottom, for aesthetic's sake.
#6UberPyro64Posted 1/25/2013 8:58:57 PM
I see. As you can see my roster in my sig is basically yours but no new Mario ro Zelda rep.
---
My SSB4 Roster: http://imageshack.us/a/img543/3938/potentialsmashreps3rost.png
#7Dustof_DryBonesPosted 1/25/2013 9:00:16 PM
liveman789 posted...
It's between them or Toad and Tingle, in my opinion. And those two are silly characters who don't have as much moveset potential as the other two.


You could just have no new Mario and Zelda reps at all. =/
---
Ahoy, matey!
#8liveman789(Topic Creator)Posted 1/25/2013 9:01:39 PM
Dustof_DryBones posted...
liveman789 posted...
It's between them or Toad and Tingle, in my opinion. And those two are silly characters who don't have as much moveset potential as the other two.


You could just have no new Mario and Zelda reps at all. =/


I wouldn't be surprised by that, either. For this particular roster, though, I gave them both another one.
#9SmashBro25Posted 1/25/2013 9:11:58 PM
This is a pretty solid roster. I know you are being cautious in terms of number of additions, but I feel you can go a little higher than 10, perhaps 12. Given that you are keeping number of newcomers low, I would cut Palutena. I would then add Ridley (again, with fewer newcomers, characters like him can get attention), one more new series or retro character (Balloon Fighter, Isaac, etc.) and one more third party, preferably Mega-Man.

I do admire your moderation though, and applaud lack of cuts. 9/10.
---
Check out Pokemon - The Abridged Series at:
http://www.youtube.com/RocketsUnderground
#10tehponycornPosted 1/25/2013 9:21:49 PM
SmashBro25 posted...
This is a pretty solid roster. I know you are being cautious in terms of number of additions, but I feel you can go a little higher than 10, perhaps 12. Given that you are keeping number of newcomers low, I would cut Palutena. I would then add Ridley (again, with fewer newcomers, characters like him can get attention), one more new series or retro character (Balloon Fighter, Isaac, etc.) and one more third party, preferably Mega-Man.

I do admire your moderation though, and applaud lack of cuts. 9/10.


Very Nice, Don't cut Palutena, still add Ridley, also, add Megaman. Also, follow SmashBro25's advice and add in one more retro character (I think Balloon Fighter will be the next WTF unexpected character.
---
Does your SSB4 roster have Shulk?...No....Then I hate it.
An Epic Fail is failing Like a Boss