How would you rate this roster...

#1GeneralPenguPosted 2/17/2013 3:19:34 PM
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Bowser
Bowser Jr.
Toad

Yoshi

Wario

Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
King K. Rool

Link
Zelda/Shiek
Ganondorf (Wind Waker)
Young Link with Masks
Toon Link
Skull Kid

Samus/Zero Suit
Ridley

Kirby
Dedede
Meta Knight
Bandana Dee

Fox
Falco

Pikachu
Unova Trainer
Meowth
Charmelon
Genesect
6th Gen Rep

Captain Falcon

Ness
Lucas
Masked Man

Ice Climbers

Marth
Ike

Game and Watch

Pit
Palutena

Olimar or Pikmin 3 character

ROB

Sonic
Snake
Dr. Eggman
Pacman
Megaman
Bomberman

Little Mac
Sukapon
Balloon Fighter
Dillon
#2Chomper4Posted 2/17/2013 3:21:06 PM
Like the Dillon part, not the MegaMan part.
#3The_KoreyPosted 2/17/2013 3:24:30 PM
Horrendus. Disasterus. Worse than my spelling.
---
The Korey: Belligerent thundering since 1988.
http://i50.tinypic.com/10y1b3t.jpg
#4albertojz356Posted 2/17/2013 3:27:04 PM
A little too many 3rd parties imo and I don't agree with no new Fire Emblem character, Awakening deserves a character. However I like the inclusion of Palutena and Meowth so.

7.5/10
---
Pauline, Palutena, Medusa, Cptn. Syrup, Mike Jones, Andy, Lip, Eirika, Bayonetta, Mr. Peepers, Micaiah, Birdo, Anna, Lyn, & Shantae for SSB4!
#5alpha-apePosted 2/17/2013 3:27:35 PM
5/10.

Most of it is good but Pokemon is screwed up and the 3rd parties aren't good.
---
Who's the strongest Donkey Kong? Brown? Green? Blue? Red? White? Black? They're gonna fight it out.
#6UberPyro64Posted 2/17/2013 3:41:43 PM(edited)
- Mario doesn't need more than 1 new rep.

- Skull Kid i irrelevant and so is the masked Link. And in NO way we need 3 Link's.

- Kirby doesn't need a 4th rep.

- I would keep all three SF characters. They fit their purpose well.

- Charmeleon? Really? Bring back normal Pokemon Trainer, Lucario and Jigglypuff and cut Unova Trainer, Charmeleon and Meowth.

- Mother is only 3 games. 2 Reps is enough.

- No new FE character? Chrom pretty damn likely to be in. More than Ike in fact.

- We don't need a second Sonic rep. Though I do like your choice Eggman regardless.

- Bomberman doesn't have good chances. Though he would be cool.

- Sukapon would be too hard to do.

- Takamaru should be in this due being a retro character that appeared inside Nintendo Land. Also Sakurai doesn't think Balloon Fighter could work but you never know.

Overall 2/10.
---
My SSB4 Roster: http://img17.imageshack.us/img17/6329/ssb4february2013rosterr.png
#7GeneralPengu(Topic Creator)Posted 2/17/2013 3:48:03 PM
UberPyro64 posted...
- Mario doesn't need more than 1 new rep.

- Skull Kid i irrelevant and so is the masked Link. And in NO way we need 3 Link's.

- Kirby doesn't need a 4th rep.

- I would keep all three SF characters. They fit their purpose well.

- Charmeleon? Really? Bring back normal Pokemon Trainer, Lucario and Jigglypuff and cut Unova Trainer, Charmeleon and Meowth.

- Mother is only 3 games. 2 Reps is enough.

- No new FE character? Chrom pretty damn likely to be in. More than Ike in fact.

- We don't need a second Sonic rep. Though I do like your choice Eggman regardless.

- Bomberman doesn't have good chances. Though he would be cool.

- Sukapon would be too hard to do.

- Takamaru should be in this due being a retro character that appeared inside Nintendo Land. Also Sakurai doesn't think Balloon Fighter could work but you never know.

Overall 2/10.


Thank you for the support, I will try and make a better roster next time.
#8a_fartn_SpartanPosted 2/17/2013 11:27:30 PM
3/10. You show clear favoritism with your reps. You cut Wolf but add 2 newcomers to the big 3 and to a series even more dead than Star Fox, which is Mother. Sorry to say but this is the worst one I've seen in a while if your going for realism. Even if your not, I still don't like this roster. Your choice of Pokemon reps bothers me. Like, over half of them.
---
Battletoads, Killer Instinct, GoldenEye, Perfect Dark, Jet Force Gemini, DK Country, Diddy Racing, Banjo, Conker.
Rare, you will be missed.
#9starrkPosted 2/17/2013 11:31:03 PM
GeneralPengu posted...

Masked Man


I wish...
---
The bigger the lie, the more they believe.