POLL: Rate My Character Roster

#1MichaelollPosted 3/2/2013 10:33:19 PM
Rate it out of 10 - Results (59 votes)
10
15.25% (9 votes)
9
9
1.69% (1 votes)
1
8
1.69% (1 votes)
1
7
10.17% (6 votes)
6
6
5.08% (3 votes)
3
5
6.78% (4 votes)
4
4
15.25% (9 votes)
9
3
5.08% (3 votes)
3
2
5.08% (3 votes)
3
1
33.9% (20 votes)
20
This poll is now closed.
Roster Pic:
http://i48.tinypic.com/10s62yg.jpg

The roster has a total of 45 character (50 with transformations, Dixie being the new one), and I think that's as large as the roster is going to get. There are 13(15) newcomers, and 3 cuts from Brawl.

Newcomers:
1. Daisy in her sports outfit
2. Diddy Kong with Dixie Kong
3. Tiny Kong
4. Toon Zelda/Tetra
5. Iris
6. New 6th gen pokemon
7. Chrom
8. Palutena
9. Shulk
10. Takamaru
11. Dillon
12. Mii
13. Pac-man

NEWCOMERS

1) DAISY in her sports outfit

The Mario series dominates Nintendo consoles, so I don't think it would be unfair if they got another rep. They did have 5 in Melee, after all. But, that 5th rep was just an undeserving clone of Mario that would have been better as an alternate costume. So then, who is deserving? In my opinion, only three characters: Daisy Bowser Jr. and Toad.

So why do I go with Daisy in the end? (1) She's a girl, which this series could certainly use a couple more of. (2) She's an actual character with history. She isn't a species like Toad nor made to be a villain out of no where. She has Super Mario Land history, heck she was made before Wario! (3) She has a great moveset potential. Daisy uses various moves throughout the spin off games she stars in. From flower powers to crystals, she can certainly be unique. (4) Toad is part of Peach's moveset while Bowser Jr. looks a bit like Bowser. Yes, Daisy looks like Peach, but the average person won't shout out clone when they see a skinny, attractive princess in her sports outfit compared to a big, bulky blondie with long hair and more weak to fight compared to this tomboy.

2) TINY KONG

One of the most obscure characters on this list. She has been in many donkey kong games in the past including Donkey Kong 64. She also appeared in Diddy Kong Racing DS, where other kongs such as funky did not appear. Nintendo clearly cares about her by keeping her new redesign. She has recently appeared in the Mario Super Sluggers that was developed by Namco. That doesn't hurt her channces. King K. Rool isn't as relevant and would be better as a boss.

3) 6TH GENERATION POKEMON

At this point, I think the only potential newcomer is a 6th generation pokemon, not Zoroark nor Genesect. Mewtwo was cut for a reason. Whatever people say is not true. They make up stories about blah blah so and so would be in but was cut at the last second due to time. No. That may have been a partial factor, but the main factor to that decision is why he probably won't return. Gen 1 is over repped and Lucario took over.

4) IRIS

This girl is more prominent and relevant than Cynthia and Dawn. People claim merchandise is the key factor to pokemon popularity. No. Iris was not only in the TV show as Ash's pal, but she was ALSO the Champion of a freaking game! Cynthia lacks constantly being in the anime while Dawn lacks being a Champion. Iris is also racially AND sexually diverse. Her pokemon? That's up to Nintendo.

5) TETRA/TOON ZELDA

With the new HD WindWaker remake combined with the fact she was a forbidden 7, her chances are pretty high compared to a 1 shot villain or a he had his chance already tingle.

6) PALUTENA

She has it all. Everyone on this board pretty much sums up she is almost guaranteed for this game. If I must explain briefly, girl, goddess, Uprising, relevant, etc.

7) CHROM

Don't know much about Fire Emblem, but people's evidence around the forums seems pretty convincing!

8) DILLON

Has an upcoming game on 3DS. If they were to re-use character models for the 3DS game, it'd be easy to shove him in/boost sales.

9) SHULK

Relevant in Xenoblade and the main character. Could rep. a unique franchise.

10) TAKAMARU

Minigame in Nintendo Land, has history, would make a nice retro.

11) PACMAN

Namco, 3rd party.

12) MII

Can represent YOU!
#2liveman789Posted 3/2/2013 10:40:20 PM(edited)
-1 for Daisy
-1 for Tiny Kong
-1 for Toon Zelda / Tetra
-1 for stealing my design with no credit!

So 6/10

EDIT: Also, some of the message is also a direct copy/paste from my past topics. It's clearly shown when you're explaining Daisy. WTF DUDE.
---
My latest Smash Bros 4 roster: http://oi46.tinypic.com/2rz99xx.jpg
#3Michaeloll(Topic Creator)Posted 3/2/2013 10:40:15 PM
Steal a design? what now??
#4CharizardFirePosted 3/2/2013 10:42:35 PM
From: Michaeloll | #001
4) IRIS

This girl is more prominent and relevant than Cynthia and Dawn. People claim merchandise is the key factor to pokemon popularity. No. Iris was not only in the TV show as Ash's pal, but she was ALSO the Champion of a freaking game! Cynthia lacks constantly being in the anime while Dawn lacks being a Champion. Iris is also racially AND sexually diverse. Her pokemon? That's up to Nintendo.

There is a 0% chance of this happening.
---
http://i458.photobucket.com/albums/qq303/CharizardFire6/Char-Brawl.gif
#5Michaeloll(Topic Creator)Posted 3/2/2013 10:47:50 PM
CharizardFire posted...
From: Michaeloll | #001
4) IRIS

This girl is more prominent and relevant than Cynthia and Dawn. People claim merchandise is the key factor to pokemon popularity. No. Iris was not only in the TV show as Ash's pal, but she was ALSO the Champion of a freaking game! Cynthia lacks constantly being in the anime while Dawn lacks being a Champion. Iris is also racially AND sexually diverse. Her pokemon? That's up to Nintendo.

There is a 0% chance of this happening.


Yeah this sounds biased. Coming from a Charizard lover one can only expect he'd be mad I took out Charizard.
#6CharizardFirePosted 3/2/2013 10:51:37 PM
From: Michaeloll | #005
CharizardFire posted...
From: Michaeloll | #001
4) IRIS

This girl is more prominent and relevant than Cynthia and Dawn. People claim merchandise is the key factor to pokemon popularity. No. Iris was not only in the TV show as Ash's pal, but she was ALSO the Champion of a freaking game! Cynthia lacks constantly being in the anime while Dawn lacks being a Champion. Iris is also racially AND sexually diverse. Her pokemon? That's up to Nintendo.

There is a 0% chance of this happening.


Yeah this sounds biased. Coming from a Charizard lover one can only expect he'd be mad I took out Charizard.

That was a joke.

Check this out: http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/661226-pokemon-black-version-2/63168080
---
http://i458.photobucket.com/albums/qq303/CharizardFire6/Char-Brawl.gif
#7liveman789Posted 3/2/2013 10:52:10 PM
Michaeloll posted...
Steal a design? what now??


You know what you did.
---
My latest Smash Bros 4 roster: http://oi46.tinypic.com/2rz99xx.jpg
#8Michaeloll(Topic Creator)Posted 3/2/2013 10:59:16 PM
CharizardFire posted...
From: Michaeloll | #005
CharizardFire posted...
From: Michaeloll | #001
4) IRIS

This girl is more prominent and relevant than Cynthia and Dawn. People claim merchandise is the key factor to pokemon popularity. No. Iris was not only in the TV show as Ash's pal, but she was ALSO the Champion of a freaking game! Cynthia lacks constantly being in the anime while Dawn lacks being a Champion. Iris is also racially AND sexually diverse. Her pokemon? That's up to Nintendo.

There is a 0% chance of this happening.


Yeah this sounds biased. Coming from a Charizard lover one can only expect he'd be mad I took out Charizard.

That was a joke.

Check this out: http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/661226-pokemon-black-version-2/63168080


is there a certain page when it is revealed then they are all shocked? XD
#9CharizardFirePosted 3/2/2013 11:01:10 PM
From: Michaeloll | #008
CharizardFire posted...
That was a joke.

Check this out: http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/661226-pokemon-black-version-2/63168080


is there a certain page when it is revealed then they are all shocked? XD

That part starts at post #22.
---
http://i458.photobucket.com/albums/qq303/CharizardFire6/Char-Brawl.gif
#10sumostickfigurePosted 3/2/2013 11:39:33 PM
... I think I would rather have a playable klaptrap than playable Tiny Kong.
---
If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face--forever.
http://i.imgur.com/Vgmi3.gif