This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Most Realistic Roster on GameFaqs Round 4!

#1xgiraffes13xPosted 3/21/2013 1:13:34 PM
Reminder I need submissions still! PM me or comment! Thank you! - Results (41 votes)
Roster 7 - http://tinypic.com/r/vqkvf5/6
48.78% (20 votes)
20
Roster 8 - http://img5.imageshack.us/img5/9560/sroster2plus.png
51.22% (21 votes)
21
This poll is now closed.
UberPyro64 won the last round with an 8 vote margin. Congratulations! This round is DasDavid vs. Doug314(Winner of our On The Fence poll). I need one more roster to face off with DynasticAnthony's in Round 5. Thank you!
---
My Dream SSB4 Roster - http://tinyurl.com/az7b2j4
3 months until E3! *fangirls*
#2xgiraffes13x(Topic Creator)Posted 3/21/2013 1:17:24 PM
*NOTICE* When voting replace Deoxys with a 6th Generation rep, creator of that roster informed me on the first poll(Nominations). Thank you!

Negatives of each roster.
Roster 7 (I really like this one so if you want to add on to problems you have please do!)
- Lloyd and No Snake
- No new LoZ or Mario rep
- No Mewtwo or Issac
- Dillon
Roster 8
- Simon and Lloyd and no Snake or Pacman
- Lip
- Black Shadow
- No Mewtwo or Lucario.. replaced by 6th gen rep
---
My Dream SSB4 Roster - http://tinyurl.com/az7b2j4
3 months until E3! *fangirls*
#3Master_Warlord7Posted 3/21/2013 1:26:06 PM(edited)
Hades is a bit out there, but after all the Kirby bias Sakurai showed, and how Sakurai can entirely get away with it because it's technically not his series, it's not beyond the realm of impossibility.

What IS within the realm of impossibility is -Anna and DEOXYS-. If we get a new Pokemon that's not gen 5/6, it'll be Mewtwo, not one from a gen literally nobody cares about right now, including the Pokemon company. Roster 8 has no idea what it's doing.

While you voters may let Mega Man bias sway you, he's far from guaranteed with Crapcom's cancerous hatred of him, whereas roster 7 has the obligatory Pac Man that roster 8 is in denial over.

EDIT: Hrm, roster 8 is significantly less cancerous without Deoxys. Still gave it to 7 anyway.
---
~~~V Smash Bros Moveset Making Paradise V~~~
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=326189
#4UberPyro64Posted 3/21/2013 1:25:21 PM
If a roster has Sonic but not Snake, it's a failure in my eyes. Both are failures. Also Anna and Lucinia over Chrom is ridiculous.
---
My SSB4 Roster: http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/7451/april2013roster.png
#5DynasticAnthonyPosted 3/21/2013 1:54:51 PM
xgiraffes13x posted...
UberPyro64 won the last round with an 8 vote margin. Congratulations! This round is DasDavid vs. Doug314(Winner of our On The Fence poll). I need one more roster to face off with DynasticAnthony's in Round 5. Thank you!


BTW, the question mark box means the 6th gen Pokemon.
---
Playing: Gears of War: Judgment | Fire Emblem: Awakening
Official Husband of Tharja <33333
#6xgiraffes13x(Topic Creator)Posted 3/21/2013 1:56:11 PM
DynasticAnthony posted...
xgiraffes13x posted...
UberPyro64 won the last round with an 8 vote margin. Congratulations! This round is DasDavid vs. Doug314(Winner of our On The Fence poll). I need one more roster to face off with DynasticAnthony's in Round 5. Thank you!


BTW, the question mark box means the 6th gen Pokemon.


On your roster? Any question mark under the Pokemon section is assumably a 6th gen rep, thanks for the confirmation though. :)
---
My Dream SSB4 Roster - http://tinyurl.com/az7b2j4
3 months until E3! *fangirls*
#7DasDavidPosted 3/21/2013 2:11:54 PM
UberPyro64 posted...
If a roster has Sonic but not Snake, it's a failure in my eyes. Both are failures. Also Anna and Lucinia over Chrom is ridiculous.


I understand the opinion about Snake and Sonic, and honestly I think it is one of the things in my roster that is the most questionable. I put the roster together that way purely because as I understand it Snake was put in Brawl more because of Kojima's request then as a result of actual demand by fans.

I personally don't see anything wrong with cutting Snake and having him maintain a legacy of being a special character that you go back in the series and play in as Brawl if you want to. Kind of like the special guests in different versions of Soul Caliber 2.

But I can't see this happening with Sonic simply because he is much more popular in general, and among Smasher, at least as far as I can tell. Still, I know it's not extremely likely, it's just something I considered when putting my roster together and deciding about the 3rd party situation.
---
-->MY<-- Latest SSB4 Roster.
http://tinypic.com/r/vqkvf5/6
#8liveman789Posted 3/21/2013 2:13:57 PM
DasDavid posted...
UberPyro64 posted...
If a roster has Sonic but not Snake, it's a failure in my eyes. Both are failures. Also Anna and Lucinia over Chrom is ridiculous.


I understand the opinion about Snake and Sonic, and honestly I think it is one of the things in my roster that is the most questionable. I put the roster together that way purely because as I understand it Snake was put in Brawl more because of Kojima's request then as a result of actual demand by fans.

I personally don't see anything wrong with cutting Snake and having him maintain a legacy of being a special character that you go back in the series and play in as Brawl if you want to. Kind of like the special guests in different versions of Soul Caliber 2.

But I can't see this happening with Sonic simply because he is much more popular in general, and among Smasher, at least as far as I can tell. Still, I know it's not extremely likely, it's just something I considered when putting my roster together and deciding about the 3rd party situation.


Also, Sonic has a consistent crossover series with Mario, and also has various exclusive Wii titles. Metal Gear doesn't really focus too much on Nintendo as much as they used to.
---
My latest Smash Bros 4 roster: http://oi46.tinypic.com/2rz99xx.jpg
#9DasDavidPosted 3/21/2013 2:19:58 PM
liveman789 posted...
DasDavid posted...
UberPyro64 posted...
If a roster has Sonic but not Snake, it's a failure in my eyes. Both are failures. Also Anna and Lucinia over Chrom is ridiculous.


I understand the opinion about Snake and Sonic, and honestly I think it is one of the things in my roster that is the most questionable. I put the roster together that way purely because as I understand it Snake was put in Brawl more because of Kojima's request then as a result of actual demand by fans.

I personally don't see anything wrong with cutting Snake and having him maintain a legacy of being a special character that you go back in the series and play in as Brawl if you want to. Kind of like the special guests in different versions of Soul Caliber 2.

But I can't see this happening with Sonic simply because he is much more popular in general, and among Smasher, at least as far as I can tell. Still, I know it's not extremely likely, it's just something I considered when putting my roster together and deciding about the 3rd party situation.


Also, Sonic has a consistent crossover series with Mario, and also has various exclusive Wii titles. Metal Gear doesn't really focus too much on Nintendo as much as they used to.


Exactly, in fact, Kojima mentioned that part of the reason he thought Snake would be a good inclusion was because of Metal Gear's lack of titles on Nintendo consoles, which to me is just kind of backwards logic.
---
-->MY<-- Latest SSB4 Roster.
http://tinypic.com/r/vqkvf5/6
#10XxWontonxXPosted 3/21/2013 2:48:19 PM
Meh both are bad, but I voted for 8
---
Chrom, Palutena, Shulk, 6th gen Pokemon, Micaiah, Female Pokemon Trainer, Roy, Ashley, and Mona for SSB4