Red Dead Redemption was the second game already, and I doubt the next game will be a direct sequel. Calling it now, it will be called "Red Dead Re(something)" and will feature no character from Redemption other than perhaps minor cameos in MP.
Red Dead Revolution is my guess. It will probably feature a character with a similar scar to Marston and Red. I think rumors were that it'll be based around the turn of the century (1900s). Who knows though. I hope they do make it, would love to see how much they can expand the world on the next gen consoles.
Redemption was set at the turn of the 20th Century.
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/569088-dragonworld Dragonworld - The Unofficial Elder Scrolls Social and Roleplay Board
Defintely Bully 2 but I wouldn`t mind a Red dead redemption prequel where you play as John in Dutch`s gang
Meh.... Another RDR would be nice, but not a prequel. There's just no story to tell with John in Dutch's gang. If they do another It will be interesting to see where they go with it. Seems like they'll have to go back in time as RDR was set at the tail end of the cowboy era, but a prequel with Marsten just wouldn't work.
I'd love to see them do Bully 2 next, though. It really is due for a sequel.
I'm so disappointed no one wants to see another Smugglers Run. I like the series back in the PS2 era and now with this current-gen, Rockstar should bring back Smugglers Run for old times sake. I wouldn't mind for an Smugglers Run HD.
Still playing Mass Effect 3 MP until Halo 4 is release. XBOX GT: Player1mj117. PSN: playmaker45.