For me, there's a very good chance. IMO, GTA4 and RDR are a tie for GOAT. I truely love both games, I really do. But a question like this is very person to person. Some will tell you SA was GOAT, other will say that Super Mario 3 was, others Zelda and so on. So I can't really answer for everybody but for me, there's a very good chance. I can't judge a game I haven't played yet either though, could you ask me October 2013? I'll have a better answer for you.
Vegetarian- an old Indian word meaning bad hunter Elected Leader of both the 360 and PS3 GTAV boards