After searching this topic I learned the box is dueling pistols. Anyway I followed and they are just standing there and I can't interact with any of them. I feel like pendleton is a mole and he told shaw to kill me in the note.
If you keep talking to him he should eventually pull out a box with the pistols. Once you pick one up, you have to walk to the cement circle a few paces away from where they are all standing. Then the countdown to the dual will start. --- LifeLongGamers - When life gets in the way of gaming. http://lifelonggamers.blog.com - New reviews/editorials on Tuesdays at 5:30pm EST!!