Why does tourney seeding favor successful players?

  • Topic Archived
  1. Boards
  2. Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3
  3. Why does tourney seeding favor successful players?
3 years ago#1
So, at big tournaments, proven-pros tend to be seeded(Placed at starting bracket/pool positions) away from other proven-pros, and given Byes when Byes are available.

Why is this?

From a competitive standpoint, nobody should have an advantage. If an advantage has to go to someone(a bye, a weak pool full of randoms), it should be random, as to avoid purposefully giving someone a competitive favor/edge.

From an ethical standpoint, Proven-pro players don't need the advantage. They're more likely to survive the first round, or the pro in their pool.

The only seeding reasons that make sense to me, are seeding members of a group apart from eachother(because you don't want to get eliminated by your roommate in the 2nd round, when you travelled 100 miles to get there; and because sponsors don't want their own investments hurting their own investments), and giving beneficial treatment(re: seeding) to people that came from further away, to promote travelling to their event.

But we get King Chris vs Baron Wong, I dun get it
Prozac is a dick.
But he's a great player. He's like the Kanye West of GameFAQs, if Kanye had talent.
3 years ago#2
I completely agree with everything you just said.
3 years ago#3
I've been saying this for years...

http://puu.sh/12RIW http://puu.sh/13ywD
http://puu.sh/12BS1 http://puu.sh/13yfX
3 years ago#4
because of the srk illuminati
3 years ago#5
iirc the justification some use for this is that they don't like the idea of the 'proven-pros' eliminating each other early.

i don't agree with it either
LunaEstFrigida on Capcom games: "SF4 = Chess, UMvC3 = Dodgeball, SFxT = Golf"
3 years ago#6
fgc got so many problems
PSN: SolidAbyss
3ds friend code: 1204-0001-5868
3 years ago#7
I hate srk, so biased.
Maximilian is God in the eyes of a child.
3 years ago#8
I'm fine with seeding, it just needs to be consistent. The FGC needs a real ranking system besides known player = get seeded
Play F-Zero GX, it's a good game http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-nGCm8CQaM
3 years ago#9
it's to keep weak players from advancing past pools and making things boring for everyone else, obviously
3 years ago#10
Prozac, you speak the truth and I agree with every word you said.
Playing UMvC3, Far Cry 3, Black Ops 2. PSN: Entropy19
  1. Boards
  2. Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3
  3. Why does tourney seeding favor successful players?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived