Do people really think Naoto is the worst party member?

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
This topic contains spoilers - you can click, tap, or highlight to reveal them
  1. Boards
  2. Persona 4 Golden
  3. Do people really think Naoto is the worst party member?

User Info: Silfurbor_Negla

Silfurbor_Negla
3 years ago#21
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik


Teddie is a good support character
If you bring him with yukiko/kanji, he can take yukiko healing/kanji matarukaja role so they can do more damaging stuff
If you bring him with yosuke and kanji, you can do 1 turn debuff and full buff (debilitate by MC followed by ma-kaja buff by the other), its more sp friendly than dragon hustle
Dragon hustle cost too much sp even with chakra ring unless you have a good stock of full sp recover item, and its a end game only skill
Where is heaven? Above the sky, and below your feet.

User Info: ArtiRock

ArtiRock
3 years ago#22
Silfurbor_Negla posted...
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik


Teddie is a good support character
If you bring him with yukiko/kanji, he can take yukiko healing/kanji matarukaja role so they can do more damaging stuff
If you bring him with yosuke and kanji, you can do 1 turn debuff and full buff (debilitate by MC followed by ma-kaja buff by the other), its more sp friendly than dragon hustle
Dragon hustle cost too much sp even with chakra ring unless you have a good stock of full sp recover item, and its a end game only skill


This.
This is the duty of the Grim Angels.

User Info: Birth_By_Sorrow

Birth_By_Sorrow
3 years ago#23
Silfurbor_Negla posted...
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik


Teddie is a good support character
If you bring him with yukiko/kanji, he can take yukiko healing/kanji matarukaja role so they can do more damaging stuff
If you bring him with yosuke and kanji, you can do 1 turn debuff and full buff (debilitate by MC followed by ma-kaja buff by the other), its more sp friendly than dragon hustle
Dragon hustle cost too much sp even with chakra ring unless you have a good stock of full sp recover item, and its a end game only skill


I never said Teddie was bad, just the worst. My gosh. Stop arguing over preference, both of you.

I did fine without a "true" healer on Very Hard. Naoto helped tremendously in that department. I have Yukiko now in my Party for my second playthrough, and I find myself much more needy as far as being healed goes. Why? Because her evasion rate/Endurance is atrocious (as is Teddies). Most of the time she's the one who needs to be healed.

I give up. I'm moving along. There are more factors here then simple buffs/healing. There are stats, hidden evasion/critical rates, etc. Sorry, this is getting tiresome. I know how I did in my own game, on Very Hard. Neither of you admits to having played through this difficulty (I did without a NG+ btw) like I have (I have experience). So I'm done.

User Info: natchu96

natchu96
3 years ago#24
Arguing over opinion never works . . .
Official Lopunny of the Black 2 Boar . . . wait, how did THAT happen?!?

User Info: ArtiRock

ArtiRock
3 years ago#25
Birth_By_Sorrow posted...
Silfurbor_Negla posted...
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik


Teddie is a good support character
If you bring him with yukiko/kanji, he can take yukiko healing/kanji matarukaja role so they can do more damaging stuff
If you bring him with yosuke and kanji, you can do 1 turn debuff and full buff (debilitate by MC followed by ma-kaja buff by the other), its more sp friendly than dragon hustle
Dragon hustle cost too much sp even with chakra ring unless you have a good stock of full sp recover item, and its a end game only skill


I never said Teddie was bad, just the worst. My gosh. Stop arguing over preference, both of you.

I did fine without a "true" healer on Very Hard. Naoto helped tremendously in that department. I have Yukiko now in my Party for my second playthrough, and I find myself much more needy as far as being healed goes. Why? Because her evasion rate/Endurance is atrocious (as is Teddies). Most of the time she's the one who needs to be healed.

I give up. I'm moving along. There are more factors here then simple buffs/healing. There are stats, hidden evasion/critical rates, etc. Sorry, this is getting tiresome. I know how I did in my own game, on Very Hard. Neither of you admits to having played through this difficulty (I did without a NG+ btw) like I have (I have experience). So I'm done.


But your strategies are not the only strategies in the world. And again, I never called Naoto bad. Worst and bad are two different words. And admitting you did something doesn't make it so. Even if you did, that doesn't mean that you are suddenly the guru of gaming. There are more strategies than the ones you use(d).

I've never been one for the "rendered obsolete" argument.
This is the duty of the Grim Angels.

User Info: Silfurbor_Negla

Silfurbor_Negla
3 years ago#26
Birth_By_Sorrow posted...
Neither of you admits to having played through this difficulty (I did without a NG+ btw) like I have (I have experience). So I'm done.


I beat very hard/risky 1st playthrough when you still waiting the NA release lol
Where is heaven? Above the sky, and below your feet.

User Info: Alekxander

Alekxander
3 years ago#27
Silfurbor_Negla posted...
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik
...

I don't want to get into the middle of an opinion argument, I just wanted to state that this isn't entirely true.
On Easy difficulty, I've killed an enemy shadow that had a listed HP of 600 with a 300 damage attack. So HP does play some factor in difficulty, though I'm not sure if it doubles in Very Hard.

User Info: thompsontalker7

thompsontalker7
3 years ago#28
I can't stand Yosuke. He does piss-poor damage and his buffs/healing aren't enough to make up for it.

My team is usually all three ladies (Chie, Yukiko, Naoto), and it works out well.
Not removing this until Dr. Dre's Detox album is out. 11/22/08
THOU ART THEE ART THOU STICK THY HAND IN TV, DO IT DO IT DO IT DO IT DO IT!

User Info: MidgardDragon99

MidgardDragon99
3 years ago#29
I hope not. She was one of my main sources of power in my first run before NG+. Mind Charge + Megidoloan is a solid little attack. Of course with Chie and Kanji both leveled up there's not as much point to using her as their Power Charge + severe damage phys attacks outdo her. But she's great for random mob clearing.

People make far too much out of who is the "best" and "worst" party member. In this game every single party makeup is viable. Everyone should really just shut up and play who they want to play and stop telling others who they are wrong for using.
3DS FC: 4639-9048-2382, Wii FC: 4558-6862-5396-5206, PSN: MidgardDragon
DD Pawn: http://game.capcom.co.jp/DD/en/pawn_detail/?pf=PS3&gid=MidgardDragon

User Info: Silfurbor_Negla

Silfurbor_Negla
3 years ago#30
Alekxander posted...
Silfurbor_Negla posted...
on Very Hard (where Shadows have double the HP and attacks do half the damage)

Difficulty doesnt affect shadow hp, its the same for all difficulty
And damage dealt on hard/very hard is indeed reduced, but not as much as it being halved afaik
...

I don't want to get into the middle of an opinion argument, I just wanted to state that this isn't entirely true.
On Easy difficulty, I've killed an enemy shadow that had a listed HP of 600 with a 300 damage attack. So HP does play some factor in difficulty, though I'm not sure if it doubles in Very Hard.


Scan only show enemy max hp, not their current hp, maybe the enemy got hit by something 1st before you kill it using the 300 damage attack

Easy example would be the secret boss
Marg diarahan always heal 15k on all difficulty
Its a solid proof that enemies hp arent affected by difficulty
Where is heaven? Above the sky, and below your feet.
  1. Boards
  2. Persona 4 Golden
  3. Do people really think Naoto is the worst party member?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived