If somebody said Scythe sucks then they NEVER SEE OROCHI, OROCHI X, and KIYOMASA OWNED EVERYTHING WITH A SCYTHE. BTW, from now on, the only cool sword main character for me would be Dante (NOT DONTE). Oh wait, he used his Ebony and Irony to owned EVERYTHING until bosses.
I never main'd them. I preferred Yuanji, Ayane, and Ryu. --- http://img202.imageshack.us/img202/841/be12546771e0f1be3d8f7d2.jpg Morning Rescue, official drink of Puella Magi!
I generally like unique weapon types that are limited to female characters (well, I guess a male character could use them too, but...ah, well....). I particularly liked FeMC's naginata, and also perhaps a whip-type weapon (Mitsuru's last weapon was the Snow Queen Whip, but it looks more like a rod/rapier).
I guess any weapon would be fine though I vastly prefer swords over everything thing else. I've always been a swordsman and it's my preferred fighting style and what I'm best at. Although, in a turn based RPG, anything is fine.
If they, for some reason, make it an action RPG, almost anything besides guns or any ranged weapons. I am not a gun user. Guns have always been a terrible play style for me in any form.
I also prefer speed, so a fast weapon is good.
Also, for the only summoning the Persona thing, I like to think that it's because it causes mental stress, or something like that, that they can't keep them out for too long.
This is actually a bit backed up by the fact that whenever a skill is used, HP or SP is used. --- Xbox Live Gamertag: Haseo8 PSN: Zichiker(made it years ago, which is why the name is terrible)
Although, I believe a gun would be a good sub weapon, in-case you do need range. Anything would be fine in a turn-based RPG though. --- Xbox Live Gamertag: Haseo8 PSN: Zichiker(made it years ago, which is why the name is terrible)