How come only Yosuke gets bashed for the Hospital incident? *spoilers*

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. Persona 4 Golden
  3. How come only Yosuke gets bashed for the Hospital incident? *spoilers*

User Info: EmeralDragon23

EmeralDragon23
3 years ago#1
yes, he was the one who insisted the most about throwing Namatame into the TV but it was Kanji who first actually suggested punishing him with the same magnitude as his crimes and Naoto who suggested throwing him into the TV and neither of them disagreed with Yosuke. In fact, it takes the longest to persuade Kanji to drop it, not Yosuke.


but Yosuke gets full blame for it for being the one to want to do it when it was in fact the three of them....
El Psy Congroo
Currently Playing: Fire Emblem: Awakening, Metroid: Other M, Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney: Justice For All, Devil Survivor: Overclocked, Madworld

User Info: Sasha_Braus

Sasha_Braus
3 years ago#2
Because Yosuke is an easy scapegoat. :D
youtu.be/sHovFcKU88g-http://i.imgur.com/sqFctZM.png
http://i.imgur.com/xKJdSXE.jpg-i.imgur.com/vsKVizo.gif

User Info: Solid_PW

Solid_PW
3 years ago#3
He was noisy as ****.
"I don't believe in maaaagiiiiicccc." - Zhang Jiao, Dynasty Warriors 3

User Info: StevenKorner

StevenKorner
3 years ago#4
Because Yosuke was the "ringleader" of that incident. Kanji was angry and wanted to throw Namatame in, but he wasn't the one negotiating with the MC. Kanji was just waiting for directions.

Meanwhile, it was Yosuke who was trying to manipulate the others into either helping throw him in or turn a blind eye. "Manipulate" has an awful connotation, I know, but that's really what he was doing. It wasn't until the MC yelled at everyone to shut up that Yosuke finally calmed down and stopped trying to convince the MC to stop stalling.

Kanji's to blame, but then again, every one of them is to blame for not being proactive about not throwing Namatame in. Yosuke is just a little more guilty because he was the one who "led the expedition," so to speak.

User Info: EmeralDragon23

EmeralDragon23
3 years ago#5
Yosuke didn't try to manipulate anyone. He said why he wanted to do it and then told them that they were free to leave if they didn't agree. It wasn't manipulation.


and again, Naoto was the one suggested throwing them into the TV and Kanji's the one who implied they should leave him to his Shadow in the first place. The scene doesn't get ugly until Kanji speaks up, which is when Rise starts getting scared, and Kanji still wants to throw Namatame in after both Yu and Yosuke agreed on not doing it, so I don't feel that he was just waiting for directions. I don't think there's a 'ringleader' anywhere. They're all equally guilty.

Kanji suggested the punishment, Naoto provided a means for it and Yosuke said why they should do it.
El Psy Congroo
Currently Playing: Fire Emblem: Awakening, Metroid: Other M, Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney: Justice For All, Devil Survivor: Overclocked, Madworld

User Info: SuperPunx64

SuperPunx64
3 years ago#6
Yosuke let his emotions take him over and didnt think things through just like everyone else (except for MC) did he's no more to blame than anyone else. People just like to bash Yosuke.
DANGANRONPA COMING TO VITA IN 2014! http://i.imgur.com/cFr7CDp.jpg
3DS: 1418-6790-0913 (Reg)

User Info: Skull007o_O

Skull007o_O
3 years ago#7
No one is to blame. I kid died and everyone was angry and not thinking at all

User Info: SlyHobbes

SlyHobbes
3 years ago#8
Skull007o_O posted...
No one is to blame. I kid died and everyone was angry and not thinking at all


Yeah... I was actually mad when it happened, even though I don't like Nanako. And that's how I got my first (bad) ending lol.
Elapsam semel occasionem non ipse potest Iuppiter reprehendere PSN: SlyHobbes

User Info: Cynrascal

Cynrascal
3 years ago#9
Yosuke gets bashed because of his bad habit of letting his emotions get the better of him. Remember how upset he got with Mitsuo, when everyone thought that Mitsuo was the killer?
http://i.minus.com/iw9Q0QNG8vIDx.gif http://i.imgur.com/lH2SX.gif

User Info: deadpool_legend

deadpool_legend
3 years ago#10
I've gone through that scene a few times and I've always paid attention to who is most adamant about throwing him into the TV. It is most certainly Yosuke. Naoto says it's a possibility and Yosuke runs with it. Kanji barely says anything. Really the only thing he says once Yu says it's a bad idea, is something to the effect of "We can't just let him go." Which doesn't even necessarily mean Kanji wanted to throw him into the TV, just that he wanted to do SOMETHING. Yosuke was the only one who definitely wanted to kill him.
"Hairy Zeus on a traffic light!"
-Deadpool, Issue #3
  1. Boards
  2. Persona 4 Golden
  3. How come only Yosuke gets bashed for the Hospital incident? *spoilers*

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived