Cloudy Moonshard: Kill or capture?

#10-172Posted 2/9/2014 9:40:17 PM
Hunting Lucent on my own I've been killing and carving to try and get a Moonshard as it seemed to be the best way to do it, but hunting with a group of friends today they said that capturing actually gave the highest chance of getting one. So, which is better?
---
Pokemon Black 2: 5415-7721-4394 / Pokemon Black: 2021-8978-9942
3DS FC: 4811-8229-7673
#2AziraphailePosted 2/9/2014 9:45:44 PM
According to kiranico.com:

Wound head: 3%
Shiny drop: 2%
Capture: 2%
Carve: 2%

So far as I know, if you can carve it from a monster's body, you're better off going for the kill. You get 3 carves, so you get to "roll the dice" a few extra times.

Just make sure you break his head first...
---
you got nothing but your asterisk, boy. so ******** and ********** to the ********************************** and *!
tribaL216
#3KalteskraabPosted 2/9/2014 9:51:57 PM
Probably one of the few monsters I'd agree that killing is the best option for a chance at it.

Eat for Carver (Hi) and put the Melynx Mask on of the little bastards to maximise your chances.
---
MH3U: All around weapon user, Gunner for Strike Team Alfred
Guild Card Title: Spelunker of Hips
#40-172(Topic Creator)Posted 2/9/2014 9:57:24 PM
Alright. That's what I thought.
---
Pokemon Black 2: 5415-7721-4394 / Pokemon Black: 2021-8978-9942
3DS FC: 4811-8229-7673
#5SmudgePosted 2/9/2014 10:01:23 PM
Thanks to Melynx mask 2/3 moonshards I've gotten were from Chacha.
---
~~~~~~
~~~~~~
#6Dark_JinougaPosted 2/10/2014 12:16:36 AM
I got the 2 for the lambent set with shiy runs, just got my second one 15min ago^^ now I neeed 1 more for mizars asterism...
---
ssslice
#7petrie911Posted 2/10/2014 12:39:44 AM
Aziraphaile posted...
According to kiranico.com:

Wound head: 3%
Shiny drop: 2%
Capture: 2%
Carve: 2%

So far as I know, if you can carve it from a monster's body, you're better off going for the kill. You get 3 carves, so you get to "roll the dice" a few extra times.

Just make sure you break his head first...


Don't you get 3 rewards for capture, making it the same number of "rolls"?
---
Belief or disbelief rests with you.
#8spaceludesPosted 2/10/2014 5:54:27 AM
petrie911 posted...

Don't you get 3 rewards for capture, making it the same number of "rolls"?


It's 2 rewards by default, 3 if you have the capture master skill. Carving is typically 3 times but goes to 4 if you have carving master skill. So for items that can be carved killing is still the route to go.

As a rule of thumb you only need to capture Lagi's and Rath's in this game and you can cap Savage Jho for black blood but kill him for everything else.
#9MartinAW4Posted 2/10/2014 7:25:28 AM
spaceludes posted...
petrie911 posted...

Don't you get 3 rewards for capture, making it the same number of "rolls"?


It's 2 rewards by default, 3 if you have the capture master skill. Carving is typically 3 times but goes to 4 if you have carving master skill. So for items that can be carved killing is still the route to go.

As a rule of thumb you only need to capture Lagi's and Rath's in this game and you can cap Savage Jho for black blood but kill him for everything else.


Lucent Nargacuga actually gives 4 body carves without the Carving Master sklil so killing is the best way to get Cloudy Moonshards and Nargacuga Mantles.
#10Immortal_hidan2Posted 2/10/2014 7:51:57 AM
Break all parts + kill gives you higher chance

Also sonic bomb him which drops a shiny has a chance too
---
Time is a great teacher, but unfortunately it kills all its pupils
0:192:0090:23321<-The code to your immortality