The reason I would have voted for Platinum if it were by itself is because of all of the "You need to go get this item before I can let you through" and "Oh look over here. You should really be sure to get this item." It's one thing to hand you the items in the story like BW2 did, but it's another to take every single bit of fun out of finding the items yourselves and having a character be a road block whose sole purpose is to make you go out of your way until you find an item you won't actually need for quite a while. And the Move Tutors were overall bad for competitive play as far as I'm concerned. Sure Superpower on things like Honchkrow and Absol was great to give them a way to get past Steel-types, but giving Salamence Outrage was what ended up making it Uber.
Now I do agree with some other things that were bad in the other games. Team Galactic and Team Plasma (BW1 only) were bad because the former had no clue what they were fighting for, the latter had lackeys that went about getting to their ideals the wrong way, and both were blatantly betrayed by their leader. At least Giovanni and the Rockets in GSC only let their team down after they got beaten by a kid numerous times. Also, competitive play was terrible in RBY simply because of the Special stat and Psychic-types utter brokenness. GSC wasn't much better due to Curse+Roar and stall in general. RSE was definitely much better due to Choice Band and the new stat mechanics, but I don't think competitive play really took off until DPPt. They added many more useable items so you weren't restricted to just Leftovers or Choice Band, they added the Physical/Special split, making Pokemon like Gengar and Sneasel actually able to use their STABs, and the Speed tiers were shaken up due to more priority moves and Choice Scarf. Gen 5 didn't really add many useful items but the changes to old moves, new Abilities, and the Dream World were great for competitive play.
As far in-game story stuff goes, I think they've gotten worse since DP and got better up until that point. RBY didn't really have much of a story (Team Rocket wasn't even trying to do anything big besides creating Mewtwo), GSC had Team Rocket trying to come back into power, and RSE had villains who constantly tried to get to an end goal, regardless of the immediate outcome. DPPt also had villains who were constantly getting to an end goal, but in a less clunky way than the RSE villains. I've already said why I think Platinum in-game was bad and BW1 was obviously better than that. BW2 had similar "Go here right now and do this to progress the story." like Pt did (if Colress had just handed you that one device and not told you where the Crustle was, it would have been fine) so they're worse than BW1, IMO.
tl;dr: RS were the worst in most areas, Pt and BW2 either handed you things or told you exactly where to get them, Gen 4 and 5 had good stories, and competitive play has gotten better and better since RBY.
Pokemon Black FC: 0475 7319 5671
From: Metleon | #061
day and night exclusives is horrible game design
In terms of gameplay mechanics, RBY is easily the worst.
As for actual enjoyment, DPPt.
The diving quest was one of the biggest pains in pokemon history. Also, it was impossible to get most of the GSP pokemon unless you also had a gamecube until they rereleased the gen 1 games.
OB64? Is that a game of some sorts? Outstanding Bounties multiplied by 64? Sounds enticing o.o
Anyone who voted Gen 1 is stupid.
Wasn't the question asked in the topic title which were the worst games? Ofcourse Gen 1 was good for it's time, but why would you play R/B/Y if you can get FR/LG which has more content? Aside from the nostalgia.
Official Dunsparce of the PMD3 board
Check my profile for FCs.
I'm rating it in terms of story, region, characters, music, Pokémon introduced, etc. Because if you rate the actual generation and its graphics/mechanics/etc, then there's less opinion involved and more just facts.
My vote is for RSE.
Pokemon Black Version 2:
Sean - 1163 7615 1957
Overall: Red/Blue because it has the least number of Pokemon.
For the time: Gold/Silver. It was neat to go to Kanto, but it just wasn't interesting for me and I hated the new Pokemon designs.
And as for Gen 4 being weak... don't you guys understand how important online is? Maybe the in game story was boring and it added a pretty low number of Pokemon, but the online thing is HUGE.
diamond/pearl/platnium is the only correct answer
diamond/pearl/platnium is the only correct answer
It's all perspective.
Just because you hated Diamond/Pearl/Platinum more does not mean everyone else does. Don't assume such either - it only makes you look like one of those overentitled people that feel that their opinion is the only real answer and should be law.
Every wound a new opportunity, every curse a new challenge.
I shall encounter defeats... But I will not be defeated.
From: Skunkdog1 | #068
platnium is the only correct answer
platnium sucked hard
platinum, however, was great
Add user to Ignore List after reporting