I chose oshawott because -I got a chimchar from the walmart special thing -I don't want 2 fire/fighting types on my team, so I didn't choose tepig (tepig is the best in my opinion though) -I am not a fan of grass types in general (no snivy) -My first starter was a water type. I really enjoyed it.
So Oshawott works really well, Tepig may be your best bet though. --- Want to see how smart you are? Click HERE to find out.
I went with Osha and it turned out to be the only Water starter I've ever liked more than the Fire starter, ever. --- What is Truth? Is it something you can see? Can touch? What is true for you may not be true for someone else.