NSMB2 is fun and all but between that and 3D land, the best choice in my opinion is 3D land. --- "I will literally murder the person of your choosing if you just let me out of here. I never even liked Marcus, just, just say the word." - Claptrap
Absolutely 3D Land. You said you've played a lot of Mario games. SM3DL will be a much more refreshing experience, combining 2D Mario-like gameplay with 3D environments. Also, it's a far better showcase of the 3DS.
--- Gamefaqs in a nutshell (http://error1355.com/img/gif/gamefaqscant.gif)