I think it was really a one sided thing. Doug is basically a background character if he is saved in ep. 1, and it's pretty forced on you to have Carley as a huge plot advancement and love interest. I would have preferred to have a chance to either injure Lilly and leave her behind (since she's in the comics and can't be killed beforehand) and lose a big leader, fighter, and intelligent, and destroy morale, or let Carley be killed. --- Why do you care so much about my signature?