I believe that Cloud is far better than Dart. However, I do believe Dart should get in over Cloud because he is first party and Cloud technically isn't. This is strictly from a technical/ factual standpoint.
Cloud and his game was PS only and his game did much MUCH more than LoD did for Sony. It was pretty much an unknowned game. Ive heard of it but i've never seen anyone actually talk about it until PSASBR. The PS1 would have done just as well w/o LoD. I really don't see how people could think Dart deserves a spot more.
FF VII got a PC port but apparently it was bad.
Who would win, Jedi Charizard or Jedi Jigglypuff? Help Robbit make it into the PSAS dlc roster! http://www.petitionbuzz.com/petitions/robbitfirstallstar
Well FF as a whole isn't really a PlayStation game, so ones like Lightning are ridiculous and should never get in. Though I understand ones like Cloud, even if there was a PC version. At least Cloud was only in the PS exclusive (console wise) games. Still, I think Dart is far less generic. Then the huge story from FF wouldn't make a big impact here, well, I certainly hope not. Then on top of that, Square Enix lifts itself pretty high, screw those guys. We could much easier get Robbit AND Dart over Cloud due to being easy first parties. I'd rather have 2. Sony would have to pay a lot less and go through less trouble.
Robbit (Jumping Flash!) definitely most wanted AND deserving for PS All-Stars Battle Royale!!! Also, Sullivan is still a dirty old man.
I hate the arguement that Cloud is generic. Cloud is only generic now because after he was made EVERYONE wanted to make their characters like Cloud. He was so unique and popular when FF7 came out that new develops used his attitude in their own games, thus making that type of character generic.
Lightning is a terrible character. Deal with it. Official Riku of the PASBR board.