How would you rank the roster in terms of "All Star" status?

#1NDgamer1122Posted 2/11/2013 9:59:47 AM
Thought this might be fun to get input on.

I'll make 5 tiers:
True PS All Star
Mostly PS All Star
Somewhat PS All Star
Barely PS All Star
Completely unrelated

So, here's mine:
True PS All Star:
Kratos
Sweet Tooth
Nathan Drake
Ratchet
Sackboy
Toro (considering Japan)

Mostly:
Radec (face of Killzone)
Sly
Cole/EvilCole
Jak
Heihachi (face of Tekken)

Somewhat:
Parappa
Sir Dan
Spike
Raiden
Fat Princess

Barely:
Dante (old Dante more a PS All Star)
Nariko

Not related:
Big Daddy
#2KindertotenwaldPosted 2/11/2013 10:00:53 AM
Swap Jak and ST and I agree.
---
PSASBR: Big Daddy
PSN: Omnisignificance
#3Myles98Posted 2/11/2013 10:02:37 AM
Jak is a true all star.

Also shouldn't all the old PS1 characters have their own tier seeing as they're not relevant anymore but back then they would have been all-stars or something.
---
Noby Noby Boy for PSASBR
PSN ID: GRANDSCENARIOS
#4CrabhammarPosted 2/11/2013 10:03:30 AM
NDgamer1122 posted...
Thought this might be fun to get input on.

I'll make 5 tiers:
True PS All Star
Mostly PS All Star
Somewhat PS All Star
Barely PS All Star
Completely unrelated

So, here's mine:
True PS All Star:
Kratos
Sweet Tooth
Nathan Drake
Ratchet
Sackboy
Toro (considering Japan)

Mostly:
Radec (face of Killzone)
Sly -> True
Cole/EvilCole
Jak -> True
Heihachi (face of Tekken)

Somewhat:
Parappa -> Mostly
Sir Dan
Spike
Raiden
Fat Princess

Barely:
Dante (old Dante more a PS All Star)
Nariko - Somewhat OR Mostly

Not related:
Big Daddy


Ratchet, Jak, and Sly are all equally the face of the PS2. Parappa was definitely known on the PS1 (dat demo disc).
#5blazin640Posted 2/11/2013 10:07:12 AM
All star is an opinion. Like how you put parappa and sir Dan as somewhat of an all star. To me they would definitely would be without question. They were one of the first.

Basically who ever you grew up with or you have nostalgia for is usually how people are going to determine All-Star.

To me, ps1 or ps2 days are all-stars, or ps3 games that set the bar for gaming standards like lbp or journey, or uncharted.
---
There goes my free time
#6wwinterj25Posted 2/11/2013 10:10:57 AM
Here you go:
:
True PS All Star:
Kratos - All PS exclusive games
Sweet Tooth - All PS exclusive games
Nathan Drake - All PS exclusive games
Ratchet - All PS exclusive games
Sackboy - All PS exclusive games
Toro (considering Japan)
Sly - All PS exclusive games
Jak - All PS exclusive games
Radec (face of Killzone) - All PS exclusive games
Cole/EvilCole - All PS exclusive games

Mostly:
Fat Princess - One game I think
Spike - Hasn't left PS
Parappa - PS exclusive
Sir Dan - Hasn't left PS in 2 games
Nariko - One game but PS exclusive

Somewhat:
Raiden - Metal gear Solid 4 is PS exsclusive same and MGS 2. MG is a PS brand to me
Heihachi (face of Tekken) - Old PS brand now multi

Barely:
Donte (old Dante more a PS All Star) - Devil May Cry started on PS if this was old Dante I'd change this but this new Dante is just Crapcom shoving this trash down our throats.

Not related:
Big Daddy
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing - GamerTag: wwinterj/PSN wwinterj
#7KillDozer123Posted 2/11/2013 10:39:12 AM
wwinterj25 posted...

Donte (old Dante more a PS All Star) - Devil May Cry started on PS if this was old Dante I'd change this but this new Dante is just Crapcom shoving this trash down our throats.


Donte isn't in this game and Crapcom does not exist. ;-) Learn to spell.
---
They see me Kahn'in'! They Hatin'!
#8NDgamer1122(Topic Creator)Posted 2/11/2013 10:44:50 AM
My reasoning for Jak and Sly only being in the mostly category and not grouped with Ratchet in the True tier is because Jak is still left behind on the PS2, and Sly only just now got one new game on the PS3. Ratchet made the transition from PS2 to PS3 early, and while the series doesn't seem to know where to go now, it's still more current. Of course, the HD collections probably helped keep them afloat and finding a new audience, so I didn't really consider that. Probably still wouldn't do much, though.

I did try to consider if they were stars in their own time. Had I not, Sir Dan and Parappa would be in an even lower tier, because they haven't been relevant for a long while. However, given I was under 10 years old when they were around, and I never played their games, then I don't really know how relevant they actually were.

Given I played the crap out of Crash and Spyro, and Final Fantasy VII and MGS1 are still highly talked about today, they would be true PS All Stars in my head.
#9Cosmic_CoyotePosted 2/11/2013 10:47:07 AM
True PS All Star

Parappa
Sir Dan
Spike
Kratos
Drake
Jak
Ratchet
Sack Boy
Sly

Mostly PS All Star

Heihachi
Cole
Toro
SweetThoot

Somewhat PS All Star

Nariko
Kat

Barely PS All Star

Fat Princess

Completely unrelated

Big Daddy
Donte
Raiden

Horrible Unknown characters:

Emmet
---
"There is no knowledge that is not power"
#10DrunkenMegamanPosted 2/11/2013 10:47:47 AM
In my opinion, everybody is a True All-Star except Fat Princess (somewhat), Dante (somewhat), Heihachi (somewhat), and Big Daddy (unrelated).
---
XBL gamertag: DrunkenMegaman/PSN: NomadicDemon54
"Was it redemption? Not really, it was pathetic desperation and not much else."- Max Payne