Convex vs concave analog sticks? *poll*

#1Mr_FOXH0UNDPosted 5/1/2013 8:48:01 AM
Which do you think is better? - Results (15 votes)
Convex (domed ps3 style)
26.67% (4 votes)
Concave (indented 360 style)
73.33% (11 votes)
This poll is now closed.
For those of you that like the rounded convex sticks over the indented ones, I'm interested to know why.

I ask this, cuz I've noticed that a lot of people order controllers purposely with the domed sticks, and some people swear by them, saying that they're significantly better.

Yes it's preference. But for me, a preference should have a logical explanation behind it.

For example, I find that the concave indented sticks have much more control cuz you can fit your thumb in the groove, which sort of locks it in place, or at least more so than the domed sticks.

I also put in a poll for fun, because hey why not...
PSN: Spathii
#2ronXwhitePosted 5/1/2013 9:04:14 AM
thumb hurts when using concave for more than like 3 hours.
[RS]Mikestasi - Proud Member of RedScreen
My first 100+ gameplay:
#3RonDijonPosted 5/1/2013 9:10:06 AM
easier to make small, presice aim adjustments with a domed stick, but the concave sticks are more stable for movement.

Scuf really has it right with their standard configuration IMO.
NNID= Based_Ron
XBL GT= ZombieFries05