I haven't enjoyed an MMO in quite a while. I enjoy ESO a great deal. It has some oldschool sensibilities that appeal to me, but I guess many are turned off by them. It also dares to be different than the pack (outside of lame duck questing).
It's a win for me. IDC what reviews say. They don't think like me, nor I them. --- The cure for a fallacious argument is a better argument, not the suppression of ideas. - Carl Sagan