"t is desperate. It is not based on what we actually know. It's not based on what we've seen. It is based on nothing other than your wish for the Xbox One version of a game to look as good as the PS4 version."
why do I wish the xbox one version looks better when I am not getting an xbox one?
It is irrelevant to me. People need to see both versions first. I would take a 720p game with better lighting, shadows and AA over 1080p with jaggies, poor quality shadows and lighting. Anyday.
That's a false dilemma. Everyone would take a better-looking game in 720p than a worse-looking one in 1080p. That's not a choice people need to make though. There's no example of this that I'm aware of, certainly not BF4 or CoD.