The real question, why aren't you guys playing your PS4s?
Seriously though, simple marketing concept on why this is probably blown out of proportion (like the PS4 fails too).
People hardly talk about good reviews and if so only to a few people usually...but a bad review they tell anyone and everyone. One both sides Xbox One and PS4 amazon number aren't true extrapolations even for amazon. Most people that had problems would go on and say so. Most positive reviews will not go on and say anything at all. Maybe 1 in 10 with a positive experience would review it....that even seems high.
Throw in that some of the 1 and 5 stars aren't even verified purchases, you simply can't trust those reviewers.
"Blood and souls for my Lord Arioch!" - Elric of Melnibone